Mike,
As I read the orders, you are correct. The Italian moves A
Mor-Spa and F Gib C A Mor-Spa are valid and unopposed. The convoy
succeeds.
Yes, this is one of the limitations of Realpolitik when it comes to
1900. I'm glad you caught this adjudication error.
Baron
=========
In a message dated 8/23/2011 1:08:43 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time,
mike(at)fuzzylogicllc.com writes:
By the way, the convoy of
Mor-Spain does succeed. This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik
that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea
(alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy
order. By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the
convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map. But know
it's there in Spain!
"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an
army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and
prevent a fleet from entering."
From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue
8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh;
mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com;
jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com;
ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com;
dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!
Penner is officially eliminated, tho it
may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England
and Turkey going from 3 to 2...
BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon
Central...
Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1
Germany: Build 1
Italy: Build 1
Turkey: Remove 1
Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A
Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste -
Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St
Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania
- Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria
Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian
Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North
Sea
Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A
Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A
Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F
Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium -
Burgundy (*Bounce*)
Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco
- Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A
Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia -
Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia
(*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean -
Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A
Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia -
Palestine
Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya -
Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople
(*Fails*)
[Reply] |
By the way, the convoy of Mor-Spain does succeed. This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea (alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy order. By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map. But know it's there in Spain!
"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and prevent a fleet from entering."
From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue 8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh; mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com; jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com; ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com; dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!
Penner is officially eliminated, tho it may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England and Turkey going from 3 to 2...
BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon Central...
Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1
Germany: Build 1
Italy: Build 1
Turkey: Remove 1
Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania - Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria
Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North Sea
Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia - Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya - Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople (*Fails*)
[Reply] |
| dc385 f05 results! (dc385) FuzzyLogic Aug 23, 03:04 pm |
By the way, the convoy of Mor-Spain does succeed. This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea (alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy order. By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map. But know it's there in Spain!
"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and prevent a fleet from entering."
From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue 8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh; mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com; jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com; ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com; dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!
Penner is officially eliminated, tho it may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England and Turkey going from 3 to 2...
BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon Central...
Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1
Germany: Build 1
Italy: Build 1
Turkey: Remove 1
Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania - Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria
Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North Sea
Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia - Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya - Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople (*Fails*)
|
| dc385 f05 results! (dc385) vonpowell Aug 23, 10:38 pm |
Mike,
As I read the orders, you are correct. The Italian moves A
Mor-Spa and F Gib C A Mor-Spa are valid and unopposed. The convoy
succeeds.
Yes, this is one of the limitations of Realpolitik when it comes to
1900. I'm glad you caught this adjudication error.
Baron
=========
In a message dated 8/23/2011 1:08:43 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time,
mike(at)fuzzylogicllc.com writes:
By the way, the convoy of
Mor-Spain does succeed. This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik
that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea
(alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy
order. By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the
convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map. But know
it's there in Spain!
"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an
army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and
prevent a fleet from entering."
From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue
8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh;
mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com;
jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com;
ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com;
dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!
Penner is officially eliminated, tho it
may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England
and Turkey going from 3 to 2...
BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon
Central...
Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1
Germany: Build 1
Italy: Build 1
Turkey: Remove 1
Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A
Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste -
Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St
Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania
- Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria
Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian
Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North
Sea
Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A
Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A
Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F
Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium -
Burgundy (*Bounce*)
Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco
- Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A
Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia -
Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia
(*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean -
Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A
Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia -
Palestine
Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya -
Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople
(*Fails*)
|
