Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

< dc355 >


 

Quick Stats:





Forum Topics:


Community
Variants
Open Games
Light Brigade
Help & Suggestions
Lost Posts
Live!


G.M.smileyrob
G.M. emailsmileyrob68-at-gmail-dot-com
TypeRegular
BuildStandard
Map1648  [Wiki]  [Stats]
VariantStandard
Cur SeasonWinter 06
Next Deadline2011-04-07 @ 22:00:00 GMT
ResultSolo
S. C.58
Players9
StatusClosed
Start Date2010-12-24
End Date2011-04-06
Real-Life Time104 days
Slideshow SC Chart dpy File
| smileyrob's House Rules | Rating Calculation
Seq Country   Player Result S.C. Seas NMRs Rtg
Chg
Rtg
New
0 Austria Captain of the Watch Silver Star9jlqueirosSolo 18 12 0 30.92 1222.31
0 Denmark Captain of the Watch Gold Star9dknemeyerSurvival 12 12 0 -2.68 1280.07
0 England Captain of the Watch Blank9charlesfAbandon 2 2 1 -5.74 1211.9
1 England Captain of the Watch Gold Star9Blueraider0Eliminated 0 6 0 -2.18 1209.12
0 France Captain of the Watch Gold Star9ddz999cat23Survival 5 12 0 -3.85 1287.1
0 Poland Esquire Blank9KnightofRomaSurvival 8 12 0 -2.18 1230.15
0 Russia Captain of the Watch Silver Star9LaneSurvival 2 12 0 -3.41 1247.48
0 Spain Captain of the Watch Silver Star9sunchungSurvival 9 12 0 -2.98 1271.62
0 Sweden Nobleman Silver Star9jonnyjagfan45Eliminated 0 8 2 -6.59 1262.29
0 Turkey Countryman Silver Star9thrashorSurvival 3 12 0 -2.52 1229.8
57

PREV  Fall 1654 Adjudication:  NEXT    

Fall 1654 will be the last meaningful season of our game, as Austria, by stabbing for Flanders and United Provinces even while accepting Spanish support into Paris, gains enough centers to secure the solo victory. Congratulations to João.

However, as I understand the rules of Diplomacy, supply centers don't officially change hands until after retreats. And here is where my inexperience as a GM leaves me wondering exactly how to proceed. There are retreats as a result of the fall orders. Should I have those powers who need to make a retreat (Poland and Spain) send in those orders, or should I just end the game now? For those that like the maps, and the colored supply centers, by adjudicating the retreat, we could have a final map showing the final ownership of centers. However that may not matter at all to some. Either way, as the game would end after the retreats, there would be no need send in winter adjustment orders.

I welcome input as to how to handle the retreat phase. I also welcome End Of Game statements. Once collected I will publish them on the game page at Diplomaticcorps.

For what it is worth, here are those retreat options:
Spanish F Brest can retreat to English Channel or Picardy or OTB.
Polish A Moscow can retreat to Onega or Permia or Voronezh or OTB.
Polish A Novgorod can retreat to Karelia or Pskov or OTB.

Thank you all for playing. I enjoyed my experience mastering a game, and am eager to do it again, maybe even immediately. I would also though like another opportunity to play in a variant featuring armed neutrals and diplomacy points, so if any of you want to GM such a game, I'd be very appreciative.

DC355: FALL 1654 ADJUDICATION

PLAYERS:
Austria: jlqueiros/João Queiros/jlqueiros3@hotmail.com
Denmark-Norway: dknemeyer/Dirk Knemeyer/dirk@knemeyer.com
England: charlesf/Charles Féaux de la Croix/charlesf@web.de (abandoned after Winter 1649)
From Spring 1650: blueraider0/Alex Maslow/Blueraider0@gmail.com
France: ddz999cat23/Daniel Dzikowicz/ddz999cat23@yahoo.com
Ottoman Empire: thrashor/Chris Hammond-Thrasher/thrasor@gmail.com
Poland-Lithuania: KnightofRoma/Daniel Eichner/Knightofroma@hotmail.com
Russia (Muscovy): Lane/Aidan Slattery/aislattery@aol.com
Spain: sunchung/Sun Chung/sun.chung@gmail.com
Sweden: jonnyjagfan45/John Gilbert/jm.gilbert@tiscali.co.uk

HEADLINES:
Austrian forces capture Moldavia, Paris, Flanders, and United Provinces, securing an Austrian victory.
Spain and France both lose centers to Austria as they are pre-occupied with fighting one another.
Danes seize Lower Saxony, but it is not enough to prevent Austrian victory.
Poles are again expelled from Russian supply centers.

ORDERS:
Austria: A Cracow - Warsaw (*Bounce*).
Austria: A Hungary - Wallachia.
Austria: F Illyria - Ionian Sea (*Bounce*).
Austria: A Lorraine - Paris.
Austria: A Lower Saxony - United Provinces.
Austria: A Prague - Slovakia (*Fails*).
Austria: A Rhineland-Westphalia - Flanders.
Austria: A Silesia - Brandenburg (*Fails*).
Austria: A Slovakia - Cracow (*Fails*).
Austria: A Switzerland - Savoy (*Fails*).
Austria: A Transylvania Supports A Wallachia - Moldavia.
Austria: A Venice - Lombardy.
Austria: A Wallachia - Moldavia.

Denmark-Norway: F Baltic Sea - Courland (*Fails*).
Denmark-Norway: F Brandenburg Hold.
Denmark-Norway: F Gulf of Bothnia Supports F Riga.
Denmark-Norway: F Helgoland Bight - Lower Saxony.
Denmark-Norway: A Holstein - Mecklenburg.
Denmark-Norway: A Ingria Supports A Onega - Novgorod.
Denmark-Norway: F Irish Sea - Cantabrian Sea.
Denmark-Norway: F Norwegian Sea Supports A Siberia - Moscow.
Denmark-Norway: A Onega - Novgorod.
Denmark-Norway: A Smolensk - Vitebsk (*Fails*).
Denmark-Norway: A Stettin Supports F Brandenburg.

France: F Aragon - Western Mediterranean.
France: A Gascony Supports A Paris - Brest.
France: A Madrid - Aragon.
France: A Paris - Brest.
France: F Portugal Hold.
France: A Seville Supports A Madrid - Aragon.

Poland-Lithuania: A Courland Supports F Riga (*Cut*).
Poland-Lithuania: A Ducal Prussia Supports A Courland.
Poland-Lithuania: A Greater Poland - Warsaw (*Bounce*).
Poland-Lithuania: A Moscow Supports A Turkestan (*Dislodged* can retreat to Onega or Permia or Voronezh or OTB).
Poland-Lithuania: A Novgorod - Onega (*Dislodged* can retreat to Karelia or Pskov or OTB).
Poland-Lithuania: A Polish Livonia Supports A Courland.
Poland-Lithuania: A Royal Prussia - Warsaw (*Bounce*).
Poland-Lithuania: A Turkestan Supports A Moscow.
Poland-Lithuania: A Vitebsk - Smolensk (*Fails*).

Russia: A Astrakhan Supports A Siberia - Moscow.
Russia: F Riga Supports F Baltic Sea - Courland.
Russia: A Siberia - Moscow.

Spain: F Brest Hold (*Dislodged* can retreat to English Channel or Picardy or OTB).
Spain: F Damascus Hold.
Spain: F Eastern Mediterranean Supports F Naples - Ionian Sea.
Spain: A Luxembourg Supports A Lorraine - Paris.
Spain: A Marseilles Supports A Lorraine - Paris.
Spain: F Naples - Ionian Sea.
Spain: F Papal States(wc) Hold.
Spain: A Savoy Supports A Marseilles (*Cut*).
Spain: F Western Mediterranean - Morocco.

Turkey: F Candia - Ionian Sea (*Fails*).
Turkey: F Constantinople - Candia (*Fails*).
Turkey: A Moldavia - Bulgaria.
Turkey: A Persia Supports A Turkestan.

Ireland: A Ireland Hold.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following units were dislodged:

Spanish F Brest can retreat to English Channel or Picardy.
Polish A Moscow can retreat to Onega or Permia or Voronezh.
Polish A Novgorod can retreat to Karelia or Pskov.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit locations:

Austria: A Cracow, A Flanders, F Illyria, A Lombardy, A Moldavia, A Paris, A
Prague, A Silesia, A Slovakia, A Switzerland, A Transylvania, A
United Provinces, A Wallachia.
Denmark-Norway: F Baltic Sea, F Brandenburg, F Cantabrian Sea, F Gulf of
Bothnia, A Ingria, F Lower Saxony, A Mecklenburg, F Norwegian Sea, A
Novgorod, A Smolensk, A Stettin.
France: A Aragon, A Brest, A Gascony, F Portugal, A Seville, F Western
Mediterranean.
Poland-Lithuania: A Courland, A Ducal Prussia, A Greater Poland, A Polish
Livonia, A Royal Prussia, A Turkestan, A Vitebsk. (A Onega/Permia/Voronezh/OTB), (A Karelia/Pskov/OTB).
Russia: A Astrakhan, A Moscow, F Riga.
Spain: F Damascus, F Eastern Mediterranean, F Ionian Sea, A Luxembourg, A
Marseilles, F Morocco, F Papal States(wc), A Savoy. (F English Channel/Picardy/OTB)
Turkey: A Bulgaria, F Candia, F Constantinople, A Persia.
Ireland: A Ireland.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ownership of supply centers (after retreats):

Austria (13-1+6=18): Bavaria, Belgrade, Lorraine, /-Lower Saxony/, Prague,
Rhineland-Westphalia, Saxony, Swabia, Switzerland, Trieste, Venice,
Vienna, Wallachia. +Cracow, +Flanders, +Moldavia, +Paris, +Transylvania, +United Provinces
Denmark-Norway (11+1=12): Abo, Brandenburg, Bristol, Christiania, Copenhagen, Holstein,
Mecklenburg, Novgorod, Scotland, Stettin, Stockholm. +Lower Saxony
France (6-2+1=5): Brest, London, Madrid, /-Papal States/, /-Paris/, Seville. +Portugal
Poland-Lithuania (9-2+1=8): Courland, /-Cracow/, Crimea, Ducal Prussia, /-Transylvania/,
Ukraine, Vilna, Voronezh, Warsaw. +Turkestan
Russia (3-1=2): Moscow, Riga, /-Turkestan/.
Spain (11-3+1=9): Algiers, Damascus, /-Flanders/, Marseilles, Morocco, Naples, /-Portugal/,
Savoy, Tunis, Tuscany, /-United Provinces/. +Papal States
Turkey (4-1=3): Candia, Constantinople, /-Moldavia/, Persia.
Ireland: Ireland.

Austria: 18 Supply centers, 13 Units: Builds 5 units. !!! VICTORY !!!
Denmark-Norway: 12 Supply centers, 11 Units: Builds 1 unit.
England: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
France: 5 Supply centers, 6 Units: Disbands 1 unit.
Poland-Lithuania: 8 Supply centers, 9(8/7) Units: Disbands 1 unit. (or builds 0 units if either Moscow or Novgorod retreat OTB, or builds 1 unit if both retreat OTB)
Russia: 2 Supply centers, 3 Units: Disbands 1 unit.
Spain: 9 Supply centers, 9(8) Units: Builds 0 units. (or builds 1 unit if Brest retreats OTB)
Sweden: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
Turkey: 3 Supply centers, 4 Units: Disbands 1 unit.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOLY ROMAN EMPEROR STANDINGS (after retreats):
Austria (current Emperor): 9 centers: Bavaria, Flanders, Lorraine, Prague, Rhineland-Westphalia, Saxony, Swabia, Trietse, Vienna
Denmark: 5 centers: Brandenburg, Holstein, Lower Saxony, Mecklenburg, Stettin
England: 0 centers
France: 0 centers
Poland: 0 centers
Russia: 0 centers
Spain: 0 centers
Sweden: 0 centers
Turkey: 0 centers
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
UPCOMING DEADLINES????:
Autumn 1654 retreats: Thursday April 7, 22:00 GMT
End of Game Statements: At your convenience

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55609 · Page loaded in 0.069 seconds by DESMOND