| DC379 - Winter Blitz - Airring the Issues - FuzzyLogic (May 30, 2011, 5:12 pm) |
Guys, it looks to me like the main issue here is the miscoloration of
Rumania. Brian is human, errors are inevitable. Even tho it was
miscolored, it did not change the builds due at the time. (all the text
results were correct). Since nobody noticed it then, I guess ppl just
didn't look closely at the map. Maybe Turkey would have ordered
differently (not to Rumania?) if he knew Rumania was not his, but really
it is the players' responsibility to assess the results and correct
anything wrong w/in 24 hours. If that didn't happen, we move on. This
is the Blitz -- We roll w the punches and the tournament keeps moving.
You can't report something was wrong in a map from over a week ago in a
tournament and have time be rewound.
Note the Mon/23 due date was obviously wrong, builds have been due on
every Friday since January - builds are clearly not due on a Monday --
in the past even.
Regarding the GM, there is no change. Brian has done an awesome job as
a first-time Blitz GM, and his efforts are hugely appreciated! If
anyone else would like to volunteer to be part of our team for next
year, let Garry or myself know. 
No doubt there are definite preferences out there regarding human GMs vs
Judge systems. Some like one, some like the other. Our group has been
a play-by-email community for 10 years and I don't think we'll ever go
to judge play.
Let's move on. Results as Brian has posted them. Next turn is due
Thursday! If you all want to vote for a draw, you can propose such w/in
the normal confines of the game, per the WB rules page... that is, you
can vote on a draw with your fall orders, but be sure to send orders too
since if the draw doesn't pass then the orders submitted are processed
with no extra time.
-mike
Co-TD,
4th Annual Winter Blitz.
-----Original Message-----
From: Trust Me [mailto:trustmedpl(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, May 30, 2011 3:26 PM
To: Dancing Queen; Gareth Griffiths; Jim Tapp; Mathew Power; Philip
King; Stuart Winch; Thomas Fletcher; blitz
Cc: Michael Sims; Garry Bledsoe
Subject: DC379 - Winter Blitz - Airring the Issues
Hey everyone:
I am copying Garry and Mike the tournament directors. Garry has
played with me as GM before so should have a little understanding of
how I GM. As a personal preference, I don't like how RealPolitik
colors the maps, so I color them by hand. This has led to a bit of a
problem.
Just to bring everyone up to date. DancingQueen, feel free to correct
me if I leave anything out. Over the course of the game, I have made
several mistakes with my adjudications and when they were brought to
my attention, I made the corrections quickly and believe they were
resolved to everyone's satisfaction, up until Winter 1908. When I
published the Winter 1908 map, I mis-colored Rumania as belonging to
Turkey rather than Austria, the SC counts however were correct,
Austria and Turkey each had the correct # of SCs and builds/removals.
No one including myself caught the mistake until After Fall 1909
adjudication. For the Fall 1909 Adjudication, I published the
builds/removals and DancingQueen questioned why he had 3 builds rather
than the 2 he was expecting when he moved to Rumania (thinking he was
moving to a territory he already owned). It was at this point that I
realized my mistake, and sent a message to everyone. Also in the Fall
1909 Adjudication, I incorrectly pubished the next deadline as Monday,
May 23rd, rather than Friday May 27th.
After the Winter 1909 Adjudication, I received a message from Dancing
Queen complaining about the incorrect deadline date. I apologized for
the mistake, but pointed out that the dates are always Spring on
Monday, Retreats on Tuesday, Fall on Thursday, and Retreat/Builds on
Friday.
Dancing Queen responded this morning expressing his displeasure with
how I have been GMing the game. All of which can be seen here as
posted to the Forum:
http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/forumPost.php?post=20782.
So that all said, I understand I made a mistake and said as much on
Friday, but really it should have been caught. As far as the deadline
goes, I would think that everyone should know by now, especially in
Year 1909 of the second game of the tournament that the deadlines are
set in stone. I have no control over them and include them as a
courtesy in my emails. If Mike and Garry would like to replace me as
GM, I will respect their opinion and gladly hand over the reins. I
will be publishing the results of Spring 1910 shortly and await the
decision of the Tournament Directors.
-- TrustMe[Reply] |
| DC379 - Spring 1910 - Results - TrustMe (May 30, 2011, 4:07 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC379 - Spring 1910 - Results (Winter Blitz) Stark May 30, 05:50 pm |
|
| DC379 - Winter Blitz - Airring the Issues - TrustMe (May 30, 2011, 3:25 pm) |
Hey everyone:
I am copying Garry and Mike the tournament directors. Garry has
played with me as GM before so should have a little understanding of
how I GM. As a personal preference, I don't like how RealPolitik
colors the maps, so I color them by hand. This has led to a bit of a
problem.
Just to bring everyone up to date. DancingQueen, feel free to correct
me if I leave anything out. Over the course of the game, I have made
several mistakes with my adjudications and when they were brought to
my attention, I made the corrections quickly and believe they were
resolved to everyone's satisfaction, up until Winter 1908. When I
published the Winter 1908 map, I mis-colored Rumania as belonging to
Turkey rather than Austria, the SC counts however were correct,
Austria and Turkey each had the correct # of SCs and builds/removals.
No one including myself caught the mistake until After Fall 1909
adjudication. For the Fall 1909 Adjudication, I published the
builds/removals and DancingQueen questioned why he had 3 builds rather
than the 2 he was expecting when he moved to Rumania (thinking he was
moving to a territory he already owned). It was at this point that I
realized my mistake, and sent a message to everyone. Also in the Fall
1909 Adjudication, I incorrectly pubished the next deadline as Monday,
May 23rd, rather than Friday May 27th.
After the Winter 1909 Adjudication, I received a message from Dancing
Queen complaining about the incorrect deadline date. I apologized for
the mistake, but pointed out that the dates are always Spring on
Monday, Retreats on Tuesday, Fall on Thursday, and Retreat/Builds on
Friday.
Dancing Queen responded this morning expressing his displeasure with
how I have been GMing the game. All of which can be seen here as
posted to the Forum:
http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/forumPost.php?post=20782.
So that all said, I understand I made a mistake and said as much on
Friday, but really it should have been caught. As far as the deadline
goes, I would think that everyone should know by now, especially in
Year 1909 of the second game of the tournament that the deadlines are
set in stone. I have no control over them and include them as a
courtesy in my emails. If Mike and Garry would like to replace me as
GM, I will respect their opinion and gladly hand over the reins. I
will be publishing the results of Spring 1910 shortly and await the
decision of the Tournament Directors.
-- TrustMe[Reply] |
| DC379 - Winter Blitz - Airring the Issues (Winter Blitz) FuzzyLogic May 30, 05:12 pm |
Guys, it looks to me like the main issue here is the miscoloration of
Rumania. Brian is human, errors are inevitable. Even tho it was
miscolored, it did not change the builds due at the time. (all the text
results were correct). Since nobody noticed it then, I guess ppl just
didn't look closely at the map. Maybe Turkey would have ordered
differently (not to Rumania?) if he knew Rumania was not his, but really
it is the players' responsibility to assess the results and correct
anything wrong w/in 24 hours. If that didn't happen, we move on. This
is the Blitz -- We roll w the punches and the tournament keeps moving.
You can't report something was wrong in a map from over a week ago in a
tournament and have time be rewound.
Note the Mon/23 due date was obviously wrong, builds have been due on
every Friday since January - builds are clearly not due on a Monday --
in the past even.
Regarding the GM, there is no change. Brian has done an awesome job as
a first-time Blitz GM, and his efforts are hugely appreciated! If
anyone else would like to volunteer to be part of our team for next
year, let Garry or myself know.
No doubt there are definite preferences out there regarding human GMs vs
Judge systems. Some like one, some like the other. Our group has been
a play-by-email community for 10 years and I don't think we'll ever go
to judge play.
Let's move on. Results as Brian has posted them. Next turn is due
Thursday! If you all want to vote for a draw, you can propose such w/in
the normal confines of the game, per the WB rules page... that is, you
can vote on a draw with your fall orders, but be sure to send orders too
since if the draw doesn't pass then the orders submitted are processed
with no extra time.
-mike
Co-TD,
4th Annual Winter Blitz.
-----Original Message-----
From: Trust Me [mailto:trustmedpl(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, May 30, 2011 3:26 PM
To: Dancing Queen; Gareth Griffiths; Jim Tapp; Mathew Power; Philip
King; Stuart Winch; Thomas Fletcher; blitz
Cc: Michael Sims; Garry Bledsoe
Subject: DC379 - Winter Blitz - Airring the Issues
Hey everyone:
I am copying Garry and Mike the tournament directors. Garry has
played with me as GM before so should have a little understanding of
how I GM. As a personal preference, I don't like how RealPolitik
colors the maps, so I color them by hand. This has led to a bit of a
problem.
Just to bring everyone up to date. DancingQueen, feel free to correct
me if I leave anything out. Over the course of the game, I have made
several mistakes with my adjudications and when they were brought to
my attention, I made the corrections quickly and believe they were
resolved to everyone's satisfaction, up until Winter 1908. When I
published the Winter 1908 map, I mis-colored Rumania as belonging to
Turkey rather than Austria, the SC counts however were correct,
Austria and Turkey each had the correct # of SCs and builds/removals.
No one including myself caught the mistake until After Fall 1909
adjudication. For the Fall 1909 Adjudication, I published the
builds/removals and DancingQueen questioned why he had 3 builds rather
than the 2 he was expecting when he moved to Rumania (thinking he was
moving to a territory he already owned). It was at this point that I
realized my mistake, and sent a message to everyone. Also in the Fall
1909 Adjudication, I incorrectly pubished the next deadline as Monday,
May 23rd, rather than Friday May 27th.
After the Winter 1909 Adjudication, I received a message from Dancing
Queen complaining about the incorrect deadline date. I apologized for
the mistake, but pointed out that the dates are always Spring on
Monday, Retreats on Tuesday, Fall on Thursday, and Retreat/Builds on
Friday.
Dancing Queen responded this morning expressing his displeasure with
how I have been GMing the game. All of which can be seen here as
posted to the Forum:
http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/forumPost.php?post=20782.
So that all said, I understand I made a mistake and said as much on
Friday, but really it should have been caught. As far as the deadline
goes, I would think that everyone should know by now, especially in
Year 1909 of the second game of the tournament that the deadlines are
set in stone. I have no control over them and include them as a
courtesy in my emails. If Mike and Garry would like to replace me as
GM, I will respect their opinion and gladly hand over the reins. I
will be publishing the results of Spring 1910 shortly and await the
decision of the Tournament Directors.
-- TrustMe |
| dc384 Ready to restart; spring retreat; deadline - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 3:19 pm) |
Hi everybody,
1. dc384 ready to restart
I'm extremely pleased to be able to tell you guys that we now have a full roster of players again for our game! Thanks to Matthias and Archer agreeing to take over Russia and Turkey respectively, we're now in a position to restart our game.
So as to allow the seven of you to get to know one another and allow the two new players plenty of time to form some strategies and alliances, I'm going to cancel the main move deadline for Autumn 1903 (which was Sunday 5 June 2000GMT), and push this back to Sunday 12 June 2000GMT. We'll restart our regular weekly pattern from there.
Autumn 1903 deadline is Sunday 12 June 2000GMT, Autumn 1903 retreats will be Monday 13 June 2000GMT, and Winter 1903 builds and disbands will be Tuesday 14 June 2000GMT. Spring 1904 deadline is Sunday 19 June 2000GMT, and so on from there.
The contact details for the seven Powers now playing our game is as follows:
ID : Avilis
Ctry : Austria 0
Name : Chris Jones
Email : raretek75(at)hotmail.com
Location : Woodbridge, SUFF, UK
ID : bschoner
Ctry : France 0
Name : Brian Schoner
Email : bschoner(at)gmail.com
Location : Norcross, GA, US
ID : carriemuirman
Ctry : Turkey 1
Name : Archer Smith
Email : archer.smith(at)zoho.com
Location : Seattle, WA, US
ID : ruler462
Ctry : Italy 0
Name : Gerry Bayer
Email : starhop8(at)gmail.com
Location : Winnipeg, MB, CA
ID : Spinoza
Ctry : Russia 1
Name : Matthias Matzinger
Email : Spinozas(at)gmx.net
Location : Zurich, CH
ID : whiterhino
Ctry : Germany 0
Name : Grant Szuveges
Email : grantszuveges(at)gmail.com
Location : Melbourne, VIC, AU
ID : zyxw59
Ctry : England 0
Name : loki falcon
Email : zyxw59(at)gmail.com
Location : Oakland, CA, US
2. Retreat from Spring
England:
F North Sea - Edinburgh
3. Deadline
Autumn 1903 moves are due Sunday 12 June 2000GMT, please.
If anybody has any questions then please do give me a shout.
Best of luck to you all!
Jerome
[Reply] |
| dc384 Ready to restart; spring retreat; deadline (dc384) jerome777 Jun 10, 04:40 pm |
|
| dc384 New Turkey saught! - carriemuirman (May 30, 2011, 2:45 pm) |
| I'd love to take over turkey. Its been a while since I've been active here, so my account is limited to one active game (and im signed up for an as-yet-unstarted game right now). I'll email the moderators to fix this [Reply] |
| dc384 New Turkey saught! (Light Brigade) trezdk Jun 08, 03:20 pm |
| If you haven't found a replacement Turkey I can take over, currently only GM'ing one game and signed up for another, so got the time |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - tfletch33 (May 30, 2011, 2:11 pm) |
Hi all,
Well I think out Turkey has played an exceptional game, I'd like to respectfully disagree with his assessment of our GM.
This is an incredibly hard tourney to Gm (I've tried, once), given the amount of flexibility in the deadlines (none). Its
alsoan incredibly difficult tourney to run and staff with volunteers.
Mistakes are bound to happen. This is a game after all.
Let's focus on the positive outcome: a very well fought game with LOT'S of twists and turns. The outcome is no longer in doubt, but for much of the game, it was.
Let's end it now with a T/A win...
Fletch
From: Christopher Martin <dance.scholar(at)gmail.com>
To: Gareth Griffiths <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com>
Cc: Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>; Winter Blitz <blitz(at)diplomaticcorp.com>; Jim Tapp
<naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com>; Thomas Fletcher <tfletch33(at)yahoo.com>; Stuart Winch <stuartandmaria(at)googlemail.com>; PhilipKing <ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com>; Mathew Power <mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, May 30, 2011 8:11 AM
Subject: Re: DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results
Hi Gareth,
Let me try to run through your points -- and no worries, I think talking about stuff is a good course of action. Perhaps I am out of line, I often am. I had a lot of time to think about this, though, and I don't think so in this case.
I do value the time of human GMs - it is why I haven't said anything until now. But a volunteer who can't do the gig should either not volunteer or should ask to be replaced.
I would have replied sooner, but I didn't have access to a keyboard until this morning. I replied to the GM immediately, but didn't appeal immediately, because the deadline published in the report wasn't until Monday. If you will recall, I did immediately point out to our GM that I didn't believe I should be building 3 - I put that in when I sent in my preliminary builds, which I did despite being on the road without access to a computer.
Of course the dot count can be fixed between Austria and myself, if everything else were equal. Everything else is not equal.
Putting it all on the table, then -- I made peace with Austria, he took a big chance walking away from me, and I promised we would take it to a 2 way draw. Since he and I went through several rounds of typical diplomacy - lying, misleading, what have you - it was very important, in this particular turn, that there be no impression of hijinx.
Jim got a copy of my orders - the ones that included the move to Rumania - and I got a copy of his - which included his fleet holding in Venice, not for nothing, and I can't ask if our GM got that wrong, because they aren't MY orders, but given the fact that I clearly can't trust his reports, I do wonder - and neither Jim nor I saw anything wrong with them.
So the diplomatic situation is screwed up, because the GM, who should be an invisible stage manager, screwed up for more than 4 seasons. It isn't the first time the map has reflected the wrong information, either - which speaks to the players responsibility to double check everything, if I want to be completely fair.
I can (will, do) also propose a 2 way Austria / Turkey draw, which is I think the result we were headed towards.
Regarding NMRs, its another reason to not play internet diplomacy. I think the equation between players failing to turn in orders (which, barring life, is a matter of 5 minutes time, and yes, sometimes that is prevented) and GMs failing to make sure they get the adjudication correct, are two different matters entirely. It is why the automated judges were coded in the first place.
Chris
On Mon, May 30, 2011 at 11:06 AM, Gareth Griffiths <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com> wrote:
Hi Chris,
I don't know why this is being blown out of proportion. Perhaps I'm
not in possession of all of the facts. If you took Rumania by
mistake because of the map then it seems Austria can be given Naples
of Greece in return quite simply (is that fleet really doing
anything? Of course it'd have been different had Austria been forced
to disband the fleet but since Austria NMR'd anyway...). But here
are my thoughts:
1. No-one is infallible, and it states in the rules that any errors
should be reported within 24 hours of an adjudication. Yes, the GM
should not have got this wrong, but why did you not pick up on it
until now?
2. If the situation were more serious (i.e. it would influence the
outcome of the game) then there'd be a reason to be annoyed, but as
I see it, you and Austria have the game wrapped up pretty neatly (or
you could go for the solo if you choose).
3. GMs volunteer their - valuable - time to adjudicate these games
for us all, and I think we should be a little more grateful.
4. This is a fast paced game with 2-4 adjudications per week.
Sometimes I find it difficult to find the time to get my orders in,
so adjudicating is going to be harder to squeeze in. Now I know that
you haven't NMR'd this game Chris, but others have, and those NMR's
have helped you perhaps more than anyone else. If we were to replace
the GM, why not replace players for NMR'ing?
5. I will agree to a DIAS if that's the will of the group, but do
not think it's very sporting.
If the above seems like I'm having a go, I'm honestly not, simply
questioning some things from your last mail that seem - to me - to
be out of order.
Gareth
On 30/05/2011 15:00, Christopher Martin wrote:
Hello all.
I've been away playing diplomacy all weekend - a great
tournament in north carolina - and I haven't had access to the
internet except over my phone.
I want to say a couple of things.
1) This is a travesty of a mockery of a sham.
2) If you are going to have an email handle like "Trust Me"
then perhaps you should take the time to make sure that people
can, in fact, trust the reports you put out, or NOT GM.
3) I don't know if it is possible in this format to request a
replacement GM but if so, I am formally requesting one.
4) Failing that, I am proposing a draw including all
survivors right now.
I've played a lot of diplomacy - in a lot of formats. I
despise the judges for their inability to handle nuance, which
is why I thought I would give a hand-adjudicated game a try.
And everyone makes mistakes.
I don't know what has been going on in "Trust Me's" life over
the last several weeks, and I don't want to judge simply because
the poor GMing have negatively impacted my game.
Jim, I am not going to reply to your last mail personally,
but I want to say publicly that I am sorry.
Chris
On Sat, May 28, 2011 at 8:26 AM, Trust
Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
Well it actually said Monday May 23rd. So obviously that
was wrong. I copy my emails and I forgot to update the
date. But Autumn/Winter is always due on Friday and Spring
is always due on Monday for this Tournament. Sorry for the
confusion.
My apologies for the sloppiness of late. I have been
extremely busy. I will try to do better.
--TrustMe
On May 28, 2011 12:55 AM,
"Dance.scholar" <dance.scholar(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
> Deadline was reported as Monday - with?
>
> Sent from my iPhone
>
> On May 27, 2011, at 7:07 AM, Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>
>> Hey all,
>>
>> Of course I messed up Germany's orders. I
must have miss clicked. In
>> this case however there is no change to the
map. So play on!
>>
>> -- TrustMe
>>
>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 3:59 AM, Gareth
Griffiths
>> <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>>> Hi everyone,
>>>
>>> Just got up and in to work so not had
much of a chance to look at what's
>>> happened, but in case it does matter, one
of my orders was wrong, it should
>>> have been:
>>>
>>> A Yorkshire Supports A Liverpool
>>> I'm sure our GM will confirm when he has
the chance.
>>>
>>> Best,
>>>
>>> Gareth (Germany)
>>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 2:09 AM, Trust Me
<trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>>>>
>>>> 379 Board:
>>>>
>>>> Austria - alhabashi - jim tapp - naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com
>>>> England - Stark - Mathew Power - mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com
>>>> France - tfletch33 - Thomas Fletcher
- tfletch33(at)yahoo.com
>>>> Germany - MagDox - Gareth Griffiths -
gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com
>>>> Italy - ilovethechiefs - Philip King
- ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com
>>>> Russia - metalwarlord - Stuart Winch
- stuartandmaria(at)gmail.com
>>>> Turkey - DancingQueen - Dancing Queen
- dance.scholar(at)gmail.com
>>>>
>>>> GM Notes:
>>>>
>>>> No moves received for England. Sorry
this is late!
>>>>
>>>> Coming up, June 13 - 17, I will be at
Scout Camp with no access
>>>> to my computer. Assuming the game is
still going, I will need to find
>>>> an alternate GM. The next week I will
be travelling for work, so
>>>> adjudications may be delayed a bit.
>>>>
>>>> Map:
>>>>
>>>> http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/hgames/dc3790903.gif
>>>>
>>>> Deadline:
>>>>
>>>> Autumn/Winter '09 is due Monday May
23rd 3 PM EDST (GMT -4) 1900 GMT
>>>>
>>>> Retreats:
>>>>
>>>> French A Burgundy can retreat to
Gascony or Ruhr or OTB.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Orders and Results:
>>>>
>>>> Austria:
>>>> A Livonia Supports A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>> A Moscow - St Petersburg
>>>> A Piedmont - Marseilles
>>>> A Silesia - Kiel
>>>> A Tyrolia - Munich
>>>> F Venice - Adriatic Sea
>>>> A Vienna - Bohemia
>>>> A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>>
>>>> England:
>>>> A Liverpool Hold
>>>> F London Hold
>>>> F Norway Hold
>>>> F Norwegian Sea Hold
>>>> A St Petersburg Hold
>>>>
>>>> France:
>>>> A Burgundy - Marseilles
>>>> F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic
Ocean
>>>> A Marseilles - Spain
>>>> A Paris - Burgundy
>>>> A Wales Hold
>>>>
>>>> Germany:
>>>> F Baltic Sea - Berlin
>>>> A Belgium Supports A Picardy -
Burgundy
>>>> A Kiel Supports A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> F North Sea - English Channel
>>>> A Picardy - Burgundy
>>>> A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> A Yorkshire Supports F Irish Sea
>>>>
>>>> Turkey:
>>>> A Bulgaria - Rumania
>>>> F Ionian Sea - Tyrrhenian Sea
>>>> F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>> F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Portugal
>>>> A Serbia - Greece
>>>> A Sevastopol - Moscow
>>>> A Tuscany - Piedmont
>>>> F Western Mediterranean Supports F
Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Supply Center and Unit Count:
>>>>
>>>> Austria: Supp 7 Unit 8 Remove 1
>>>> England: Supp 5 Unit 5
>>>> France: Supp 4 Unit 5 Remove 1
>>>> Germany: Supp 7 Unit 7
>>>> Italy: eliminated
>>>> Russia: eliminated
>>>> Turkey: Supp 11 Unit 8 Build 3
>>>
>>>[Reply] |
| dc384 New Russia saught! - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 11:49 am) |
Hi everybody,
OK so I've found a new Russia, unsurprisingly it wasn't too difficult as Russia is in a pretty good position. Still looking for a new Turkey, however - so if you fancy playing the Sultan, please give me a shout!
jerome777[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - DancingQueen (May 30, 2011, 11:11 am) |
[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - MagDox (May 30, 2011, 10:06 am) |
Hi Chris,
I don't know why this is being blown out of proportion. Perhaps I'm
not in possession of all of the facts. If you took Rumania by
mistake because of the map then it seems Austria can be given Naples
of Greece in return quite simply (is that fleet really doing
anything? Of course it'd have been different had Austria been forced
to disband the fleet but since Austria NMR'd anyway...). But here
are my thoughts:
1. No-one is infallible, and it states in the rules that any errors
should be reported within 24 hours of an adjudication. Yes, the GM
should not have got this wrong, but why did you not pick up on it
until now?
2. If the situation were more serious (i.e. it would influence the
outcome of the game) then there'd be a reason to be annoyed, but as
I see it, you and Austria have the game wrapped up pretty neatly (or
you could go for the solo if you choose).
3. GMs volunteer their - valuable - time to adjudicate these games
for us all, and I think we should be a little more grateful.
4. This is a fast paced game with 2-4 adjudications per week.
Sometimes I find it difficult to find the time to get my orders in,
so adjudicating is going to be harder to squeeze in. Now I know that
you haven't NMR'd this game Chris, but others have, and those NMR's
have helped you perhaps more than anyone else. If we were to replace
the GM, why not replace players for NMR'ing?
5. I will agree to a DIAS if that's the will of the group, but do
not think it's very sporting.
If the above seems like I'm having a go, I'm honestly not, simply
questioning some things from your last mail that seem - to me - to
be out of order.
Gareth
On 30/05/2011 15:00, Christopher Martin wrote:
Hello all.
I've been away playing diplomacy all weekend - a great
tournament in north carolina - and I haven't had access to the
internet except over my phone.
I want to say a couple of things.
1) This is a travesty of a mockery of a sham.
2) If you are going to have an email handle like "Trust Me"
then perhaps you should take the time to make sure that people
can, in fact, trust the reports you put out, or NOT GM.
3) I don't know if it is possible in this format to request a
replacement GM but if so, I am formally requesting one.
4) Failing that, I am proposing a draw including all
survivors right now.
I've played a lot of diplomacy - in a lot of formats. I
despise the judges for their inability to handle nuance, which
is why I thought I would give a hand-adjudicated game a try.
And everyone makes mistakes.
I don't know what has been going on in "Trust Me's" life over
the last several weeks, and I don't want to judge simply because
the poor GMing have negatively impacted my game.
Jim, I am not going to reply to your last mail personally,
but I want to say publicly that I am sorry.
Chris
On Sat, May 28, 2011 at 8:26 AM, Trust
Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
Well it actually said Monday May 23rd. So obviously that
was wrong. I copy my emails and I forgot to update the
date. But Autumn/Winter is always due on Friday and Spring
is always due on Monday for this Tournament. Sorry for the
confusion.
My apologies for the sloppiness of late. I have been
extremely busy. I will try to do better.
--TrustMe
On May 28, 2011 12:55 AM,
"Dance.scholar" <dance.scholar(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
> Deadline was reported as Monday - with?
>
> Sent from my iPhone
>
> On May 27, 2011, at 7:07 AM, Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>
>> Hey all,
>>
>> Of course I messed up Germany's orders. I
must have miss clicked. In
>> this case however there is no change to the
map. So play on!
>>
>> -- TrustMe
>>
>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 3:59 AM, Gareth
Griffiths
>> <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>>> Hi everyone,
>>>
>>> Just got up and in to work so not had
much of a chance to look at what's
>>> happened, but in case it does matter, one
of my orders was wrong, it should
>>> have been:
>>>
>>> A Yorkshire Supports A Liverpool
>>> I'm sure our GM will confirm when he has
the chance.
>>>
>>> Best,
>>>
>>> Gareth (Germany)
>>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 2:09 AM, Trust Me
<trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
wrote:
>>>>
>>>> 379 Board:
>>>>
>>>> Austria - alhabashi - jim tapp - naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com
>>>> England - Stark - Mathew Power - mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com
>>>> France - tfletch33 - Thomas Fletcher
- tfletch33(at)yahoo.com
>>>> Germany - MagDox - Gareth Griffiths -
gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com
>>>> Italy - ilovethechiefs - Philip King
- ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com
>>>> Russia - metalwarlord - Stuart Winch
- stuartandmaria(at)gmail.com
>>>> Turkey - DancingQueen - Dancing Queen
- dance.scholar(at)gmail.com
>>>>
>>>> GM Notes:
>>>>
>>>> No moves received for England. Sorry
this is late!
>>>>
>>>> Coming up, June 13 - 17, I will be at
Scout Camp with no access
>>>> to my computer. Assuming the game is
still going, I will need to find
>>>> an alternate GM. The next week I will
be travelling for work, so
>>>> adjudications may be delayed a bit.
>>>>
>>>> Map:
>>>>
>>>> http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/hgames/dc3790903.gif
>>>>
>>>> Deadline:
>>>>
>>>> Autumn/Winter '09 is due Monday May
23rd 3 PM EDST (GMT -4) 1900 GMT
>>>>
>>>> Retreats:
>>>>
>>>> French A Burgundy can retreat to
Gascony or Ruhr or OTB.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Orders and Results:
>>>>
>>>> Austria:
>>>> A Livonia Supports A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>> A Moscow - St Petersburg
>>>> A Piedmont - Marseilles
>>>> A Silesia - Kiel
>>>> A Tyrolia - Munich
>>>> F Venice - Adriatic Sea
>>>> A Vienna - Bohemia
>>>> A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>>
>>>> England:
>>>> A Liverpool Hold
>>>> F London Hold
>>>> F Norway Hold
>>>> F Norwegian Sea Hold
>>>> A St Petersburg Hold
>>>>
>>>> France:
>>>> A Burgundy - Marseilles
>>>> F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic
Ocean
>>>> A Marseilles - Spain
>>>> A Paris - Burgundy
>>>> A Wales Hold
>>>>
>>>> Germany:
>>>> F Baltic Sea - Berlin
>>>> A Belgium Supports A Picardy -
Burgundy
>>>> A Kiel Supports A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> F North Sea - English Channel
>>>> A Picardy - Burgundy
>>>> A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> A Yorkshire Supports F Irish Sea
>>>>
>>>> Turkey:
>>>> A Bulgaria - Rumania
>>>> F Ionian Sea - Tyrrhenian Sea
>>>> F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>> F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Portugal
>>>> A Serbia - Greece
>>>> A Sevastopol - Moscow
>>>> A Tuscany - Piedmont
>>>> F Western Mediterranean Supports F
Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Supply Center and Unit Count:
>>>>
>>>> Austria: Supp 7 Unit 8 Remove 1
>>>> England: Supp 5 Unit 5
>>>> France: Supp 4 Unit 5 Remove 1
>>>> Germany: Supp 7 Unit 7
>>>> Italy: eliminated
>>>> Russia: eliminated
>>>> Turkey: Supp 11 Unit 8 Build 3
>>>
>>>[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - DancingQueen (May 30, 2011, 9:00 am) |
[Reply] |
| dc374 Spring '10 Results - notasb (May 30, 2011, 8:24 am) |
Board:
Austria Matthew ODonnell - eliminated '06
England Alex Phillips
France Warren Fleming
Germany Hugh Polley - eliminated '08
Italy Mark Weiskircher - eliminated '04
Russia Jeremiah Lee
Turkey Andrew Cassese
Deadline:
Fall '10 is due Thursday June 2nd 8 AM CDST (GMT -5) 1300 GMT
Orders and Results:
England:
F Baltic Sea - Berlin
A Denmark Supports F Kiel
F English Channel - North Sea
F Holland Supports F North Sea - Helgoland Bight
F Kiel Supports F Baltic Sea - Berlin (*Cut*)
A London - Yorkshire
F North Sea - Helgoland Bight
A Sweden - Norway (*Fails*)
France:
F Brest, no move received
A Gascony - Burgundy
F Gulf of Lyon - Tyrrhenian Sea (*Fails*)
F Marseilles - Spain(sc) (*Fails*)
A Paris - Picardy
A Spain - Portugal
A Trieste - Venice
Russia:
A Budapest - Vienna
F Helgoland Bight - North Sea (*Disbanded*)
A Moscow - St Petersburg
A Munich - Kiel (*Fails*)
F Norway Supports F Helgoland Bight - North Sea (*Cut*)
A Serbia - Budapest
F St Petersburg(sc) - Finland
A Tyrolia Supports A Albania - Trieste
A Ukraine - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
Turkey:
F Adriatic Sea Supports A Albania - Trieste
A Albania - Trieste
F Black Sea Supports A Sevastopol
A Greece - Bulgaria
F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Spain(nc)
A Piedmont - Marseilles (*Fails*)
A Rumania Supports A Greece - Serbia (*Void*)
A Sevastopol Supports A Rumania (*Cut*)
F Tyrrhenian Sea - Gulf of Lyon (*Fails*)
F Western Mediterranean Supports F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Spain(nc)
Forced Disband:
Russian F Helgoland Bight has no retreats, disbanded.
------------
"An ideal form of government is democracy tempered with assassination." -Voltaire[Reply] |
| dc384 Two new Powers saught - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 7:49 am) |
Hi everyone,
Unfortunately Sean (Russia) has had to drop out of our game, due to some pretty serious personal issues that are going to need to occupy his spare time. Therefore we're now in a position of needing two replacement players to fill up our board.
I've posted messages in the Light Brigade section of the dc website, and we'll see what kind of response those messages get. In the meantime, I'll keep you all posted as best I can with news on our game.
Best,
Jerome [Reply] |
| dc384 New Russia saught! - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 7:43 am) |
Hi everyone,
Yes, it's me again! Another opening has now appeared in the dc384 game, this time for Russia. Russia is in an eminently playable condition, and a commission in the Light Brigade awaits whomever is willing to take up the mantle with this Power.
Standard rules, one major season per week (deadlines 2000GMT Sunday evenings).
If you've any questions, please shout.
best
jerome777[Reply] |
| dc384 New Russia saught! (Light Brigade) jerome777 May 30, 11:49 am |
Hi everybody,
OK so I've found a new Russia, unsurprisingly it wasn't too difficult as Russia is in a pretty good position. Still looking for a new Turkey, however - so if you fancy playing the Sultan, please give me a shout!
jerome777 |
| dc384 New Turkey saught! - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 3:28 am) |
Hi everyone,
The opportunity you've always wanted to come and be a replacement in a good ol' standard game of Dip has arrived!
Yes, that's right! Come and join in a game with us all - a commission in the Light Brigade awaits you. A chance to take over a reasonable position as Turkey in dc384 has arisen, just send me an email if you'd like to take over the position and I'll put you in there. It's first-come-first-served, so don't delay, join up today!
Standard rules, one major season per week (deadlines 2000GMT Sunday evenings).
If you've any questions, please shout.
best
jerome777[Reply] |
| dc384 New Turkey saught! (Light Brigade) carriemuirman May 30, 02:45 pm |
| I'd love to take over turkey. Its been a while since I've been active here, so my account is limited to one active game (and im signed up for an as-yet-unstarted game right now). I'll email the moderators to fix this |
| dc384 New Turkey saught! (Light Brigade) trezdk Jun 08, 03:20 pm |
| If you haven't found a replacement Turkey I can take over, currently only GM'ing one game and signed up for another, so got the time |
| dc384 Spring 1903 adjudication - jerome777 (May 30, 2011, 3:22 am) |
"Rioting in the streets of Constantinople, Ankara, Smyrna - Turkish general sacked and new leader saught!"
"Tsar fails to issue orders to Russian units!"
"Italians fail to find missing cat in Bulgaria despite extensive search - Rumania now thought to be most likely hiding place!"
"French President demands interesting new dishes for his meals at court - Liverpool invaded in search of exotic new cuisine such as 'scouse', 'pea-whack' and 'wet nelly'!"
Anonymous press: "Italian diplomat heard yelling 'Let's get ready to Rum Bul !!!!!!' "
Hi everyone,
Apologies for the late adjudication of the game this season. I had a minor emergency to deal with last night, so thanks for your patience.
Unfortunately we've two NMRs this season, despite several reminders sent to the players concerned asking them to submit their moves. So, we need to wave 'goodbye' to one player - thanks for playing Vinnie - and I'll search for a replacement to take over Vinnie's role.
In the meantime, we've one retreat needed from England, so Luke - please let me know what you'd like to do with your NTH fleet as soon as possible. The deadline for this retreat ought to be 2000GMT tonight, but given my lateness in adjudicating this move I'll stretch this to 0800GMT tomorrow (Tuesday 31 May). Having said this, if you can let me know your retreat sooner, I'll adjudicate as soon as possible.
I'm going to begin the search for a new Turkey now. Once a new Turkey is appointed, I'll give an extended deadline to you all to allow Diplomacy with the new player, and give him/her a chance to get to know you all. If I can appoint a new Turkey before Sunday 5 June, the deadline for Autumn 03 moves will be Sunday 13 June 2000GMT.
Spring 03 moves:
Austria:
A Budapest Supports A Bulgaria - Rumania
A Serbia Supports A Bulgaria - Rumania
A Trieste Supports A Budapest
F Tunis - Ionian Sea
A Vienna - Galicia (*Fails*)
England:
F London Hold
F North Sea Supports F London (*Dislodged*)
A Yorkshire - Liverpool (*Fails*)
France:
A Belgium Hold
F Brest - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
F English Channel Supports F Skagerrak - North Sea
F Irish Sea Supports A Wales - Liverpool
A Spain - Gascony
A Wales - Liverpool
Germany:
A Denmark Supports F Sweden
F Helgoland Bight Supports F Skagerrak - North Sea
A Holland Supports A Belgium
A Munich - Silesia
F Skagerrak - North Sea
Italy:
A Apulia - Venice
A Bulgaria - Rumania
F Greece Supports F Ionian Sea - Aegean Sea
F Ionian Sea - Aegean Sea
F Naples - Apulia
Russia:
A Galicia, no move received
A Moscow, no move received
F Norway, no move received
A Rumania, no move received (*Disbanded*)
F Sevastopol, no move received
F Sweden, no move received
A Warsaw, no move received
Turkey:
F Ankara, no move received
F Eastern Mediterranean, no move received
A Smyrna, no move received
Retreat required:
English fleet NTH retreats to either Edi, NWG or OTB.
Take it easy everyone,
Jerome
[Reply] |
| dc378 spring 10 - catsfather (May 30, 2011, 1:13 am) |
Deadline (9pm GMT tonight) approaching. If you've not had a
"received" from me then the odds are that I don't have your orders.
Hamish[Reply] |
| dc378 spring 10 (Winter Blitz) catsfather May 31, 01:12 am |
Retreat due for the English fleet in Norway.
Movement results for Spring of 1910. (dc37
Austria: A Albania - Serbia.
Austria: A Budapest - Rumania.
Austria: A Rumania - Bulgaria.
Austria: A Trieste Hold.
Austria: A Vienna - Budapest.
England: F Denmark Supports F Skagerrak - North Sea.
England: F Norway Supports F Skagerrak - North Sea (*Dislodged*).
England: F Skagerrak - North Sea.
France: A Apulia Hold.
France: F Belgium - North Sea (*Fails*).
France: A Burgundy Hold.
France: A Edinburgh - Norway (*Fails*).
France: F Marseilles, no move received.
France: F Naples Supports F Tyrrhenian Sea - Ionian Sea.
France: F North Atlantic Ocean Hold.
France: F North Sea - Norway.
France: F Norwegian Sea Supports F North Sea - Norway.
France: A Tyrolia - Piedmont.
France: F Tyrrhenian Sea - Ionian Sea (*Bounce*).
France: A Venice Hold.
France: F Western Mediterranean - Tunis.
Germany: F Berlin - Baltic Sea.
Germany: A Holland Supports F Kiel.
Germany: F Kiel Supports F Berlin - Baltic Sea.
Germany: A Moscow - Sevastopol.
Germany: A Munich Supports F Kiel.
Germany: A Sevastopol - Armenia.
Germany: A St Petersburg Supports F North Sea - Norway.
Turkey: F Aegean Sea - Ionian Sea (*Bounce*).
Turkey: F Black Sea - Constantinople.
Turkey: A Constantinople - Smyrna.
Turkey: F Greece Supports F Aegean Sea - Ionian Sea.
Turkey: F Ionian Sea - Adriatic Sea.
The following units were dislodged:
English F Norway can retreat to Sweden or Barents Sea or Skagerrak.
Unit locations:
Austria: A Budapest, A Bulgaria, A Rumania, A Serbia, A Trieste.
England: F Denmark, F North Sea.
France: A Apulia, F Belgium, A Burgundy, A Edinburgh, F Marseilles, F
Naples, F North Atlantic Ocean, F Norway, F Norwegian Sea, A
Piedmont, F Tunis, F Tyrrhenian Sea, A Venice.
Germany: A Armenia, F Baltic Sea, A Holland, F Kiel, A Munich, A Sevastopol,
A St Petersburg.
Turkey: F Adriatic Sea, F Aegean Sea, F Constantinople, F Greece, A Smyrna.
Ownership of supply centers:
Austria: Budapest, Rumania, Serbia, Trieste, Vienna.
England: Denmark, Norway, Sweden.
France: Belgium, Brest, Edinburgh, Liverpool, London, Marseilles, Naples,
Paris, Portugal, Rome, Spain, Tunis, Venice.
Germany: Berlin, Holland, Kiel, Moscow, Munich, Sevastopol, St Petersburg,
Warsaw.
Turkey: Ankara, Bulgaria, Constantinople, Greece, Smyrna.
Austria: 5 Supply centers, 5 Units: Builds 0 units.
England: 3 Supply centers, 2 Units: Builds 0 units.
France: 13 Supply centers, 13 Units: Builds 0 units.
Germany: 8 Supply centers, 7 Units: Builds 1 unit.
Italy: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
Russia: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
Turkey: 5 Supply centers, 5 Units: Builds 0 units.
The next phase of dc378 will be Retreats for Spring of 1910. |
| DC 387: Spring 1901 adjud - Blueraider0 (May 29, 2011, 12:44 pm) |
[Reply] |
| dc384 Spring 1903 22hrs reminder - jerome777 (May 28, 2011, 4:41 pm) |
Hi everyone,
The deadline is just over 22 hours away for dc384. The deadline for your Spring 1903 moves is 2000GMT Sunday 29 May.
I'm sure we are all hoping for no NMRs (no moves received) this turn, though you should all be aware that two consecutive NMRs will result in a replacement player being sought for your Power.
Vamos Barca!
Jerome[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - TrustMe (May 28, 2011, 7:26 am) |
Well it actually said Monday May 23rd. So obviously that was wrong. I copy my emails and I forgot to update the date. But Autumn/Winter is always due on Friday and Spring is always due on Monday for this Tournament. Sorry for the confusion.
My apologies for the sloppiness of late. I have been extremely busy. I will try to do better.
--TrustMe
On May 28, 2011 12:55 AM, "Dance.scholar" <dance.scholar(at)gmail.com> wrote:
> Deadline was reported as Monday - with?
>
> Sent from my iPhone
>
> On May 27, 2011, at 7:07 AM, Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Hey all,
>>
>> Of course I messed up Germany's orders. I must have miss clicked. In
>> this case however there is no change to the map. So play on!
>>
>> -- TrustMe
>>
>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 3:59 AM, Gareth Griffiths
>> <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Hi everyone,
>>>
>>> Just got up and in to work so not had much of a chance to look at what's
>>> happened, but in case it does matter, one of my orders was wrong, it should
>>> have been:
>>>
>>> A Yorkshire Supports A Liverpool
>>> I'm sure our GM will confirm when he has the chance.
>>>
>>> Best,
>>>
>>> Gareth (Germany)
>>> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 2:09 AM, Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> 379 Board:
>>>>
>>>> Austria - alhabashi - jim tapp - naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com
>>>> England - Stark - Mathew Power - mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com
>>>> France - tfletch33 - Thomas Fletcher - tfletch33(at)yahoo.com
>>>> Germany - MagDox - Gareth Griffiths - gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com
>>>> Italy - ilovethechiefs - Philip King - ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com
>>>> Russia - metalwarlord - Stuart Winch - stuartandmaria(at)gmail.com
>>>> Turkey - DancingQueen - Dancing Queen - dance.scholar(at)gmail.com
>>>>
>>>> GM Notes:
>>>>
>>>> No moves received for England. Sorry this is late!
>>>>
>>>> Coming up, June 13 - 17, I will be at Scout Camp with no access
>>>> to my computer. Assuming the game is still going, I will need to find
>>>> an alternate GM. The next week I will be travelling for work, so
>>>> adjudications may be delayed a bit.
>>>>
>>>> Map:
>>>>
>>>> http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/hgames/dc3790903.gif
>>>>
>>>> Deadline:
>>>>
>>>> Autumn/Winter '09 is due Monday May 23rd 3 PM EDST (GMT -4) 1900 GMT
>>>>
>>>> Retreats:
>>>>
>>>> French A Burgundy can retreat to Gascony or Ruhr or OTB.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Orders and Results:
>>>>
>>>> Austria:
>>>> A Livonia Supports A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>> A Moscow - St Petersburg
>>>> A Piedmont - Marseilles
>>>> A Silesia - Kiel
>>>> A Tyrolia - Munich
>>>> F Venice - Adriatic Sea
>>>> A Vienna - Bohemia
>>>> A Warsaw - Prussia
>>>>
>>>> England:
>>>> A Liverpool Hold
>>>> F London Hold
>>>> F Norway Hold
>>>> F Norwegian Sea Hold
>>>> A St Petersburg Hold
>>>>
>>>> France:
>>>> A Burgundy - Marseilles
>>>> F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>> A Marseilles - Spain
>>>> A Paris - Burgundy
>>>> A Wales Hold
>>>>
>>>> Germany:
>>>> F Baltic Sea - Berlin
>>>> A Belgium Supports A Picardy - Burgundy
>>>> A Kiel Supports A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> F North Sea - English Channel
>>>> A Picardy - Burgundy
>>>> A Ruhr - Munich
>>>> A Yorkshire Supports F Irish Sea
>>>>
>>>> Turkey:
>>>> A Bulgaria - Rumania
>>>> F Ionian Sea - Tyrrhenian Sea
>>>> F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>> F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Portugal
>>>> A Serbia - Greece
>>>> A Sevastopol - Moscow
>>>> A Tuscany - Piedmont
>>>> F Western Mediterranean Supports F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Supply Center and Unit Count:
>>>>
>>>> Austria: Supp 7 Unit 8 Remove 1
>>>> England: Supp 5 Unit 5
>>>> France: Supp 4 Unit 5 Remove 1
>>>> Germany: Supp 7 Unit 7
>>>> Italy: eliminated
>>>> Russia: eliminated
>>>> Turkey: Supp 11 Unit 8 Build 3
>>>
>>>[Reply] |
| dc378 winter 09 - catsfather (May 28, 2011, 5:49 am) |
Sorry, I have no excuse for results being later than late.
French fleet Ion retreats to Nap (perhaps some shore leave was what
they prayed for) and the English army in StP disbands.
Adjustment orders for Winter of 1909. (dc37
Austria: Build A Budapest.
England: Remove F Helgoland Bight.
France: Build F Marseilles.
Turkey: Remove F Eastern Mediterranean.
Unit locations:
Austria: A Albania, A Budapest, A Rumania, A Trieste, A Vienna.
England: F Denmark, F Norway, F Skagerrak.
France: A Apulia, F Belgium, A Burgundy, A Edinburgh, F Marseilles, F
Naples, F North Atlantic Ocean, F North Sea, F Norwegian Sea, A
Tyrolia, F Tyrrhenian Sea, A Venice, F Western Mediterranean.
Germany: F Berlin, A Holland, F Kiel, A Moscow, A Munich, A Sevastopol, A St
Petersburg.
Turkey: F Aegean Sea, F Black Sea, A Constantinople, F Greece, F Ionian Sea.
Ownership of supply centers:
Austria: Budapest, Rumania, Serbia, Trieste, Vienna.
England: Denmark, Norway, Sweden.
France: Belgium, Brest, Edinburgh, Liverpool, London, Marseilles, Naples,
Paris, Portugal, Rome, Spain, Tunis, Venice.
Germany: Berlin, Holland, Kiel, Moscow, Munich, Sevastopol, St Petersburg,
Warsaw.
Turkey: Ankara, Bulgaria, Constantinople, Greece, Smyrna.
Austria: 5 Supply centers, 5 Units: Builds 0 units.
England: 3 Supply centers, 3 Units: Builds 0 units.
France: 13 Supply centers, 13 Units: Builds 0 units.
Germany: 8 Supply centers, 7 Units: Builds 0 units.
Italy: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
Russia: 0 Supply centers, 0 Units: Builds 0 units.
Turkey: 5 Supply centers, 5 Units: Builds 0 units.
The next phase of dc378 will be Movement for Spring of 1910.[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - DancingQueen (May 27, 2011, 11:55 pm) |
Deadline was reported as Monday - with?
Sent from my iPhone
On May 27, 2011, at 7:07 AM, Trust Me wrote:
Hey all,
Of course I messed up Germany's orders. I must have miss clicked. In
this case however there is no change to the map. So play on!
-- TrustMe
On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 3:59 AM, Gareth Griffiths
wrote:
> Hi everyone,
>
> Just got up and in to work so not had much of a chance to look at what's
> happened, but in case it does matter, one of my orders was wrong, it should
> have been:
>
> A Yorkshire Supports A Liverpool
> I'm sure our GM will confirm when he has the chance.
>
> Best,
>
> Gareth (Germany)
> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 2:09 AM, Trust Me wrote:
>>
>> 379 Board:
>>
>> Austria - alhabashi - jim tapp - naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com
>> England - Stark - Mathew Power - mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com
>> France - tfletch33 - Thomas Fletcher - tfletch33(at)yahoo.com
>> Germany - MagDox - Gareth Griffiths - gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com
>> Italy - ilovethechiefs - Philip King - ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com
>> Russia - metalwarlord - Stuart Winch - stuartandmaria(at)gmail.com
>> Turkey - DancingQueen - Dancing Queen - dance.scholar(at)gmail.com
>>
>> GM Notes:
>>
>> No moves received for England. Sorry this is late!
>>
>> Coming up, June 13 - 17, I will be at Scout Camp with no access
>> to my computer. Assuming the game is still going, I will need to find
>> an alternate GM. The next week I will be travelling for work, so
>> adjudications may be delayed a bit.
>>
>> Map:
>>
>> http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/hgames/dc3790903.gif
>>
>> Deadline:
>>
>> Autumn/Winter '09 is due Monday May 23rd 3 PM EDST (GMT -4) 1900 GMT
>>
>> Retreats:
>>
>> French A Burgundy can retreat to Gascony or Ruhr or OTB.
>>
>>
>> Orders and Results:
>>
>> Austria:
>> A Livonia Supports A Warsaw - Prussia
>> A Moscow - St Petersburg
>> A Piedmont - Marseilles
>> A Silesia - Kiel
>> A Tyrolia - Munich
>> F Venice - Adriatic Sea
>> A Vienna - Bohemia
>> A Warsaw - Prussia
>>
>> England:
>> A Liverpool Hold
>> F London Hold
>> F Norway Hold
>> F Norwegian Sea Hold
>> A St Petersburg Hold
>>
>> France:
>> A Burgundy - Marseilles
>> F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>> A Marseilles - Spain
>> A Paris - Burgundy
>> A Wales Hold
>>
>> Germany:
>> F Baltic Sea - Berlin
>> A Belgium Supports A Picardy - Burgundy
>> A Kiel Supports A Ruhr - Munich
>> F North Sea - English Channel
>> A Picardy - Burgundy
>> A Ruhr - Munich
>> A Yorkshire Supports F Irish Sea
>>
>> Turkey:
>> A Bulgaria - Rumania
>> F Ionian Sea - Tyrrhenian Sea
>> F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>> F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Portugal
>> A Serbia - Greece
>> A Sevastopol - Moscow
>> A Tuscany - Piedmont
>> F Western Mediterranean Supports F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>
>>
>> Supply Center and Unit Count:
>>
>> Austria: Supp 7 Unit 8 Remove 1
>> England: Supp 5 Unit 5
>> France: Supp 4 Unit 5 Remove 1
>> Germany: Supp 7 Unit 7
>> Italy: eliminated
>> Russia: eliminated
>> Turkey: Supp 11 Unit 8 Build 3
>
>[Reply] |
| dc342 ~ Imperial 1841 - sgttodd (May 27, 2011, 8:44 pm) |
The deadline for Spring 1851 orders is: Tuesday, May 31st (at) 2359
UTC.
The Ottomans did not submit disbands so the software was
allowed to select them.
Adjustment orders for Winter of 1850.
Austria: Build F Venice.
Austria: Build A Vienna.
Britain: Build A Zanguebar.
Britain: Build F New Guinea.
Ottoman: Defaults, removing A Mandlah.
Ottoman: Defaults, removing F Mecca.
Ottoman: Defaults, removing F Red Sea.
USA: Build A Charleston.
USA: Build F Boston.
USA: Build F Cape Colony.
Unit locations:
Austria: F Venice, A Vienna, A Paris, A Marseilles, A Holland, F
Denmark, A Greece, F Kiel(wc), A Rome, F Salerno, A Piedmont, F
Rouen, F Sicily, F Baltic Sea.
Britain: F Bombay, F Malaysia, F Borneo, F New Guinea, F Madrid, A
Zanguebar, F Norway, A Catalunia, A Ethiopia, A Hadramaut, F Madras,
A Siam, F Barents Sea, F North Sea, F Skagerrak, F Horn of Africa, F
Arabian Sea, F Barrier Sea, F Coral Sea, F Phillipene Sea.
China: A Delhi, F Guangdong, F Kagoshima, A Hue, F Kamchatka, A
Korea, A Tibet, A Hunan, A Yunnan, A Sapporo, F Formosa, F Tai Won,
F China Sea, F Eastern Sea, F Sea of Japan, F Kuril Sea.
Holland: F South Austrailia.
Ottoman: F Bagdad, A Egypt, A Kuar, A Nubia.
Russia: F Constantinople, A St Petersburg, A Rumania, F Sweden, A
Armenia, A Finland, A Livonia, A Tehran, A Hyderabad, A Nejaaz, A
Punjab, F Eastern Mediterranean.
Spain: A Guinea, F Phillipines, A Donga, A Hahira, F Somolia, F
Fujian, F Solomons, F Marshalls, A Alaska, F Gulf of Lyon, F Ionian
Sea, F Sargasso Sea, F Roaring Forties, F N.W.Indian Ocean, F Java
Sea, F Celebes Sea, F Bering Sea, F N.W.Pacific Ocean, F Izu Sea, F
W.Pacific Ocean, F N.Pacific Ocean, F Gulf of Alaska.
USA: F Cape Colony, F Nantes, A Antilles, F Sierra Leone, F
Boston, A Charleston, A Bordeaux, A Coruna, A Abyssinia, F Tunisia,
A Fezzan, A Mozambique, F Norwegian Sea, F Helgoland Bight, F
English Channel, F Bay of Biscay, F Tyrrhenian Sea, F Canaries
Seaway, F N.Atlantic Ocean, F Mozabaique Channel.
files: http://mainecav.org/diplomacy[Reply] |
| DC379 - Autumn/Winter 1909 - Results - TrustMe (May 27, 2011, 6:59 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results - tfletch33 (May 27, 2011, 5:41 pm) |
Hi all,
Looks like a very nice Turkish solo to me.
Well down Dancing Queen!
TF
From: Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com>
To: Gareth Griffiths <gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com>
Cc: Dancing Queen <dance.scholar(at)gmail.com>; Jim Tapp <naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com>; Mathew Power <mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com>; Philip King <ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com>; Stuart Winch <stuartandmaria(at)googlemail.com>; Thomas Fletcher <tfletch33(at)yahoo.com>; Winter Blitz <blitz(at)diplomaticcorp.com>
Sent: Friday, May 27, 2011 3:07
AM
Subject: Re: DC379 - Fall 1909 - Results
Hey all,
Of course I messed up Germany's orders. I must have miss clicked. In
this case however there is no change to the map. So play on!
-- TrustMe
On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 3:59 AM, Gareth Griffiths
<gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi everyone,
>
> Just got up and in to work so not had much of a chance to look at what's
> happened, but in case it does matter, one of my orders was wrong, it should
> have been:
>
> A Yorkshire Supports A Liverpool
> I'm sure our GM will confirm when he has the chance.
>
> Best,
>
> Gareth (Germany)
> On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 2:09 AM, Trust Me <trustmedpl(at)gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> 379 Board:
>>
>> Austria - alhabashi - jim tapp - naamanbathing(at)yahoo.com
>> England - Stark - Mathew Power - mathew.t.power(at)gmail.com
>> France - tfletch33 - Thomas Fletcher - tfletch33(at)yahoo.com
>> Germany - MagDox - Gareth Griffiths - gnr.griffiths(at)gmail.com
>> Italy - ilovethechiefs - Philip King - ilovethechiefs(at)gmail.com
>> Russia - metalwarlord - Stuart Winch - stuartandmaria(at)gmail.com
>> Turkey - DancingQueen - Dancing Queen - dance.scholar(at)gmail.com
>>
>> GM Notes:
>>
>> No moves received for England. Sorry this is late!
>>
>> Coming up, June 13 - 17, I will be at Scout Camp with no access
>> to my computer. Assuming the game is still going, I will need to find
>> an alternate GM. The next week I will be travelling for work, so
>> adjudications may be delayed a bit.
>>
>> Map:
>>
>> http://www.diplomaticcorp.com/hgames/dc3790903.gif
>>
>> Deadline:
>>
>> Autumn/Winter '09 is due Monday May 23rd 3 PM EDST (GMT -4) 1900 GMT
>>
>>
Retreats:
>>
>> French A Burgundy can retreat to Gascony or Ruhr or OTB.
>>
>>
>> Orders and Results:
>>
>> Austria:
>> A Livonia Supports A Warsaw - Prussia
>> A Moscow - St Petersburg
>> A Piedmont - Marseilles
>> A Silesia - Kiel
>> A Tyrolia - Munich
>> F Venice - Adriatic Sea
>> A Vienna - Bohemia
>> A Warsaw - Prussia
>>
>> England:
>> A Liverpool Hold
>> F London Hold
>> F Norway Hold
>> F Norwegian Sea Hold
>> A St Petersburg Hold
>>
>> France:
>> A Burgundy - Marseilles
>> F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>> A Marseilles - Spain
>> A Paris - Burgundy
>> A Wales Hold
>>
>> Germany:
>> F Baltic Sea - Berlin
>> A Belgium Supports A Picardy -
Burgundy
>> A Kiel Supports A Ruhr - Munich
>> F North Sea - English Channel
>> A Picardy - Burgundy
>> A Ruhr - Munich
>> A Yorkshire Supports F Irish Sea
>>
>> Turkey:
>> A Bulgaria - Rumania
>> F Ionian Sea - Tyrrhenian Sea
>> F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>> F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Portugal
>> A Serbia - Greece
>> A Sevastopol - Moscow
>> A Tuscany - Piedmont
>> F Western Mediterranean Supports F Irish Sea - Mid-Atlantic Ocean
>>
>>
>> Supply Center and Unit Count:
>>
>> Austria: Supp 7 Unit 8 Remove 1
>> England: Supp 5 Unit 5
>> France: Supp 4 Unit 5 Remove 1
>> Germany: Supp 7 Unit 7
>> Italy: eliminated
>> Russia:
eliminated
>> Turkey: Supp 11 Unit 8 Build 3
>
>[Reply] |
| dc384 Spring 1903 48hrs reminder - ruler462 (May 27, 2011, 3:11 pm) |
[Reply] |
