| DC 341: W1904 - AceRimmer (Nov 15, 2010, 10:17 am) |
England plops a fleet in Liverpool
Russia summons an army in Warsaw
Italy dismantles an army in Naples
Spring 1905 will be on Friday, November 19th, at 10:00 CST (16:00 GMT).[Reply] |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question - FuzzyLogic (Nov 15, 2010, 9:49 am) |
I would argue that, since there is not an unbroken chain of fleets running from Belgium to NAf, the army's order is invalid and should be treated as A Bel Holds.
I would insist that[Reply] |
| Reply notification (Community) AceRimmer Nov 15, 10:56 am |
| "I would insist that the valid set of moves for a unit are not dependent on the lack or presence of other units. I think if you order A Lon-Pic, even if there is no fleet in ENG, it is as valid a mov |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 15, 11:20 am |
| I see the logic, it just seems you should be able to determine if a unit's order is valid w/o regard for other units' positions. i.e. you can take a blank board, put a single unit on Lon and say "Is |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) Blueraider0 Nov 19, 01:49 am |
| If that's the case, when would an order ever be invalid or illegal? I suppose attempting to move a unit that is not one's own, or ordering a unit that does not exist is invalid, But even then, you sa |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 19, 08:48 am |
We're in agreement here, no? I can't quite tell these examples are so wacky. 
Therefore Lon to Bel might be illegal because of other units.
Lon-Bel is valid even if yo |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) AceRimmer Nov 19, 11:17 am |
Maslow, I'm going to agree with poobaloo here: your post is discussing semantics / word games.
Chiefly, you seem to be trying to define a difference between invalid and illegal. I'm guessing that |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 19, 12:05 pm |
So, perhaps, I should restate the issue at hand as I see it:
When should a GM declare that a unit's order is unadjudicable and therefore defaults to 'Unit Holds'?
Ok, so what |
| dc337 - Summer 1906 Results - z93blom (Nov 15, 2010, 5:13 am) |
[Reply] |
| DC 338 Spring 06 Results - derekthefeared2 (Nov 14, 2010, 8:28 pm) |
No moves from Russia this time. Hopefully they will be around to send moves for the fall. Fall 06 Orders will be due this Friday Nov 19th at 3:00 PM US Eastern time.
The Aus[Reply] |
| DC348 - trezdk (Nov 14, 2010, 6:58 pm) |
You are in
DC348 should be underway real soon  [Reply] |
| DC348 - Lane (Nov 14, 2010, 4:03 pm) |
I'd like to join your game if there is still a vacancy
LANE[Reply] |
| DC348 (Open Games) trezdk Nov 14, 06:58 pm |
You are in
DC348 should be underway real soon |
| DC348 - trezdk (Nov 14, 2010, 3:02 pm) |
We need a new player for DC348.
We havent assigned countries yet so everything is open still
The build rules are imperial aka you can build in any start home center you own.
So send me a m[Reply] |
| DC348 (Open Games) Lane Nov 14, 04:03 pm |
I'd like to join your game if there is still a vacancy
LANE |
| DC348 (Open Games) trezdk Nov 14, 06:58 pm |
You are in
DC348 should be underway real soon |
| dc330: Wi44 Results! - dknemeyer (Nov 14, 2010, 12:47 pm) |
Hi Everyone,
I am very schedule-driven, and Thursday is my adjudication day. So, with the day shifted to Friday, I plumb forgot about it entirely! Oy vey...
For those who submitted draw vote[Reply] |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication - bielf11 (Nov 13, 2010, 6:53 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication - FuzzyLogic (Nov 13, 2010, 6:23 pm) |
Is Aetolia not entitled to retreat dislodged units, even despite the NMR?
From: DipCorp Master [mailto:dipcorp.master(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, November 13, 2010 5:54 PM
[b[Reply] |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication - bielf11 (Nov 13, 2010, 5:53 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC327 - Another RP error - bielf11 (Nov 13, 2010, 5:35 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication - bielf11 (Nov 13, 2010, 3:46 pm) |
[Reply] |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication (dc327) bielf11 Nov 13, 05:53 pm |
|
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication (dc327) FuzzyLogic Nov 13, 06:23 pm |
Is Aetolia not entitled to retreat dislodged units, even despite the NMR?
From: DipCorp Master [mailto:dipcorp.master(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, November 13, 2010 5:54 PM
[b |
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication (dc327) bielf11 Nov 13, 06:53 pm |
|
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication (dc327) evapollo88 Nov 15, 10:21 pm |
|
| DC327 - Spring 12 adjudication (dc327) FuzzyLogic Nov 16, 08:18 am |
Is there any end to this game? Anything ppl want to vote?
From: Gregory Olson [mailto lson.gregoryscott(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Mon 11/15/2010 10:21 PM
To: leq |
| dc334 s06 results! - FuzzyLogic (Nov 13, 2010, 7:46 am) |
The Thessalian fleet retreats to Pag! Map later.
Fall 6 due Friday 11/19, 3pm Central…
From: Michael Sims
Sent: Thursday, November 04, 2010 2:11[Reply] |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question - Blueraider0 (Nov 13, 2010, 12:12 am) |
| Aahhhh, dang it I apparently didn't actually post my response. Crud, and it was so brilliant and funny and intellectually stunning! Well, here's take 2. And if it sucks, just know there is a better [Reply] |
| dc342 ~ Imperial 1841 - sgttodd (Nov 12, 2010, 10:53 pm) |
Deadline for Summer 1844 retreats: Monday, November 15th (at) 2359
UTC.
The following units were dislodged:
Spanish A Metz can retreat to Rouen.
Aus[Reply] |
| DC 338 Spring 06 Reminder - derekthefeared2 (Nov 12, 2010, 10:18 pm) |
Reminder that spring 06 orders are due this sunday at 3:00 pm US eastern time. If you haven't sent in orders yet, get them in.
Thanks.[Reply] |
| dc342 ~ Imperial 1841 - sgttodd (Nov 12, 2010, 6:03 pm) |
The deadline for Spring 1844 orders is being extended to 0359 UTC
today by request.
[Reply] |
| DC 333, Fall 1906 - alwayshunted (Nov 12, 2010, 6:00 pm) |
Hi folks,
The two way draw.... fails. There is a new proposal now for a three way, FRANCE, TURKEY, RUSSIA draw. Votes for this will be due with the spring 1907 orders.
&[Reply] |
| dc307 ~ Orient Express - sgttodd (Nov 12, 2010, 5:57 pm) |
Deadline for Fall 1916 orders; Tuesday, November 16th (at) 2359 UTC.
The following units were dislodged:
Indonesian F Australia retreats to South Indian Ocean.[Reply] |
| DC 336 Spring '05 Adjudication - mgsmuhammad (Nov 12, 2010, 2:18 pm) |
Austria
A Rum to Ukr *bounce*
A Bud supports Vie
A Vie to hold
F Tri to Adr
A Rom to hold
F Ven to hold
A Ger to Ser
A Bul to Rum *bounce*
Germany
A Mun-Tyr
A Boh S A Mun - Tyr
A G[Reply] |
| DC 341: A very befuddled F1904 - AceRimmer (Nov 12, 2010, 12:04 pm) |
After this season, we may need a clinic on movement orders.
First, the fleet on the east coast of Bulgaria cannot move to Aegean Sea or Greece. Nor can it support units to move to or hold in those p[Reply] |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question - AceRimmer (Nov 12, 2010, 10:23 am) |
Generally, I agree with poobaloo's interpretations.
Maslow and I did go back to the rulebook. Maslow pointed out the rule stating "An Army can be ordered to move into an adjacent inland or coastal[Reply] |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) Blueraider0 Nov 13, 12:12 am |
| Aahhhh, dang it I apparently didn't actually post my response. Crud, and it was so brilliant and funny and intellectually stunning! Well, here's take 2. And if it sucks, just know there is a better |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 15, 09:49 am |
I would argue that, since there is not an unbroken chain of fleets running from Belgium to NAf, the army's order is invalid and should be treated as A Bel Holds.
I would insist that |
| Reply notification (Community) AceRimmer Nov 15, 10:56 am |
| "I would insist that the valid set of moves for a unit are not dependent on the lack or presence of other units. I think if you order A Lon-Pic, even if there is no fleet in ENG, it is as valid a mov |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 15, 11:20 am |
| I see the logic, it just seems you should be able to determine if a unit's order is valid w/o regard for other units' positions. i.e. you can take a blank board, put a single unit on Lon and say "Is |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) Blueraider0 Nov 19, 01:49 am |
| If that's the case, when would an order ever be invalid or illegal? I suppose attempting to move a unit that is not one's own, or ordering a unit that does not exist is invalid, But even then, you sa |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 19, 08:48 am |
We're in agreement here, no? I can't quite tell these examples are so wacky.
Therefore Lon to Bel might be illegal because of other units.
Lon-Bel is valid even if yo |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) AceRimmer Nov 19, 11:17 am |
Maslow, I'm going to agree with poobaloo here: your post is discussing semantics / word games.
Chiefly, you seem to be trying to define a difference between invalid and illegal. I'm guessing that |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Community) FuzzyLogic Nov 19, 12:05 pm |
So, perhaps, I should restate the issue at hand as I see it:
When should a GM declare that a unit's order is unadjudicable and therefore defaults to 'Unit Holds'?
Ok, so what |
| For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question - AceRimmer (Nov 12, 2010, 10:14 am) |
Maslow, I'd say that your question is rendered moot by the section of the rules entitled:
"Support" Cannot Be Convoyed.
At least that puzzle is easily solved [Reply] |
| DC 345: The One Who Will Win Retreats - AceRimmer (Nov 12, 2010, 9:22 am) |
No secret here. F Nwy-Nth. F Den-Hel.
Winter adjustments (due Monday):
DRE: Supp 2 Unit 3 Remove 1
Adaria: Supp 7 Unit 6 Build 1
Itea: Supp 2 Unit 2 Build 0
The_One_Who_W[Reply] |
