Diplomaticcorp - Forum Post

Welcome Guest! [Log In] [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum: dc265

(Standard - European Onion)

Messages:

New Post
List of Topics
Recent Messages

Preview:

Compact
Brief
Full

Replies:

Hide All
Show All

Post:	< 12104 >
Subject:	< Re: dc265 ~ European Onion >
Topic:	< dc265 >
Category:	< Closed Games
Author:	ccr
Posted:	Jul 29, 2009 at 5:33 am
Viewed:	1057 times

Rating: 0

Member Since	Location
Dec 31, 1969	Unknown

[New Post] [Reply] [Quote]

Hi! I have just asked to join as Italy.

And I already have a comment.

Austrian F retreating from Greece can retreat to Albania or Ionian Sea. The GM retreated it to the Ionian, if Austria would prefer otherwise, please notify me ASAP!

I ask you not to do this in the future in any games you GM. When a player have options, the GM cannot assume his choices. Cannot decide the player do what makes more sense. Cannot decide something is obvious.

As Italy, I argue to Austria that given Turk and Russian moves were anti-Austria, and given Italy is facing french southern drive, then Italy and Austria must to be ally on the defense, and if Austria don't do that then Italy will play suicide against Austria. And that if Austria retreats to Alb, then Italy will move to ION just next, and help against Greece, if by the time the french will have already realized he must be more careful about the lots of idle german armies before committing his units far away from home.

Also note that GM interference is not right because it goes against your own house rules, section 8, and it hurts another topic of the same rules, section 5.

8. If I can skip a retreat phase because all retreating units only have 1 possible retreat, I will order the retreats and skip to the next phase.

Not the case. You must allow the 24 hours to receive a valid retreat order.

5. An NMR on a retreat phase means the unit disbands.

And after the 24 hours, if the unit remain unordered, it is disbanded. How do you want to apply rule 5, if you give orders for the players?

CCR

This message is in reply to post 11668:

Deadline for Fall 1901: Monday, July 6; 2359 UTC

Movement results for Spring of 1901. (dc265)

Austria: A Budapest - Serbia.
Austria: F Trieste - Albania.
Austria: A Vienna - Trieste.

England: F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea.
England: A Liverpool - Yorkshire.
England: F London - North Sea.

France: F Brest - Mid-Atlantic Ocean.
France: A Marseilles - Burgundy (*Bounce*).
France: A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*).

Germany: A Berlin - Kiel.
Germany: F Kiel - Holland.
Germany: A Munich - Ruhr.

Italy: F Naples - Ionian Sea.
Italy: A Rome - Venice.
Italy: A Venice - Tyrolia.

Russia: A Moscow - Ukraine.
Russia: F Sevastopol - Rumania.
Russia: F St Petersburg(sc) - Gulf of Bothnia.
Russia: A Warsaw - Galicia.

Turkey: F Ankara - Constantinople.
Turkey: A Constantinople - Bulgaria.
Turkey: A Smyrna Hold.

Unit locations:

Austria: F Albania, A Serbia, A Trieste.
England: F North Sea, F Norwegian Sea, A Yorkshire.
France: A Marseilles, F Mid-Atlantic Ocean, A Paris.
Germany: F Holland, A Kiel, A Ruhr.
Italy: F Ionian Sea, A Tyrolia, A Venice.
Russia: A Galicia, F Gulf of Bothnia, F Rumania, A Ukraine.
Turkey: A Bulgaria, F Constantinople, A Smyrna.

The next phase of dc265 will be Movement for Fall of 1901.
Deadline for Fall 1901: Monday, July 6; 2359 UTC
files: http://mainecav.org/diplomacy

There are 30 Messages in this Thread:

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Jun 30, 09:31 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Jul 07, 08:38 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Jul 09, 11:19 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Jul 25, 09:56 am

Re: dc265 ~ European Onion (ccr) Jul 29, 05:33 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Jul 29, 07:45 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 03, 10:02 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 05, 12:08 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 08, 12:22 am

News from Switzerland (ccr) Aug 09, 08:42 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 13, 10:27 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 18, 10:49 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 19, 11:24 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 24, 10:09 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Aug 29, 08:38 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Sep 07, 04:27 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Sep 08, 08:14 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Sep 15, 02:50 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Sep 22, 09:33 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Sep 25, 10:11 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Oct 02, 10:15 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Oct 05, 09:03 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Oct 17, 11:46 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Oct 20, 07:19 pm

Unknown (sgttodd) Nov 04, 09:36 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Nov 04, 09:37 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Nov 09, 10:07 pm

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Nov 14, 10:29 am

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) Nov 15, 08:38 pm

There are 4 Threads in dc265:

dc265 ~ European Onion (sgttodd) [29 Replies]

dc265 ~European Onion (sgttodd)

Football (Joral)

RE001 = DC265 ~ The European Onion (sgttodd)

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.