Game Page

Welcome Guest! [Log In] [Sign Up]

< dc293 >

WB10 Round 1

Forum Topics:

Community
Variants
Open Games
Light Brigade
Help & Suggestions
Lost Posts
Live!

G.M.	AceRimmer
G.M. email	smegdwarf-at-yahoo-dot-com
Type	Tournament
Build	Standard
Map	Standard
Variant	Standard
Cur Season	Spring 10
Next Deadline	2010-03-15 @ 16:00:00 GMT
Result	2-Way Draw
S. C.	34
Players	7
Status	Closed
Start Date	2010-01-04
End Date	2010-03-12
Real-Life Time	68 days

\| Rating Calculation

Seq	Country	Player	Result	S.C.	Seas	NMRs	Rtg Chg	Rtg New
0	Austria	Stepper	Eliminated	0	6	0	-5.7	1197.06
0	England	ericjmarr	Survival	4	19	1	-3.41	1226.48
0	France	billyjoebobfred1	Survival	3	19	4	-3.34	1194.22
0	Germany	Jeremiah	Eliminated	0	14	1	-5.21	1208.56
0	Italy	phantomas13	Eliminated	0	16	1	-4.55	1186.81
0	Russia	Corrino	Draw	15	19	0	10.27	1313.98
0	Turkey	JeffreyK	Draw	12	19	0	11.97	1254.48
				34

PREV Winter 1905 Adjudication: NEXT

Hey guys, Adam asked me to check the orders box since one player said he ccâ€™d missing orders there. They were indeed there, and on time, so they are to be counted!

* France builds A Mar *

Everything else is the same.

*****

Alright... so today's adjudication is an educational opportunity in the strictness of Winter Blitz rules and the it-falls-on-the-shoulders-of-the-player-even-when-the-GM-is-totally-out-of-touch interpretations. Explanations in a minute...

F1905R:
German A Kiel - Ruhr
German A Warsaw - Ukraine

W1905:
England: Remove F Berlin
France: Build waived
Germany: Remove A Ukraine
Remove F Helgoland Bight
Italy: Remove A Apulia
Russia: Build A Moscow
Build F St Petersburg(nc)
Turkey: Build A Smyrna

So, Germany submitted a retreat order but failed to include an adjustment order... and as the rules state, Fall Retreats and Winter Adjustments are adjudicated simultaneously. The Ukrainian army and Helgoland fleet were disbanded in accordance with tournament rules on NBRs. I will check with the tournament moderators to see whether this will lead to an NMR in club stats or not.
France is away from home and is using an alternate email address... or, at least he did so for Fall 1905. The problem is: I didn't realize until now that this inconvenience would extend until today. Consequently, I only emailed the Fall adjudication to his usual inbox. A gentle, kind, and loving GM would postpone the adjudication and give France a second chance. But a Winter Blitz tournament GM would note that: (a) the adjudications were posted to the DC website for all the public to behold, and (b) it is the player's responsibility to contact the GM if he has not received the adjudication. In short, the tournament does not allow for leniency, no matter how much the GM can empathize with the player. France NBRs.

S1906 is on Monday!

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.