Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  Help & Suggestions

(How can we make diplomaticcorp.com better?)


Post:< 22334 >
Subject:< auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs >
Topic:< Help & Suggestions >
Category:General >
Author:FuzzyLogic
Posted:Feb 02, 2012 at 1:19 pm
Viewed:1331 times

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

Blue had a lot of good points. In fact I don't think I could have expressed them better.

As to dc, we were created to be a friendly gaming group, not an automated move submission "system". Because people get personally vested in these games, I think it leads to a higher caliber of game than what you'll find on one of the automated submission sites.

Remember Dip is at heart, an interpersonal game.

A "system" could be more methodical in many ways. Always on time, never making mistakes -- But board games do not generally exist w such dynamics. I don't know how much you play Face to Face... but in those games, things get hectic. There are people complaining about someone turning in moves past the buzzer, ppl arguing about legibility, and so on. It is human-judgement oriented. We have strived to deliberately keep that human element to the game.

In any case, here another fundamental is that every GM sets his or her own rules. This leads to a diverse array of styles being enjoyed.

Some GM's will give grace periods. Some will run faster games. Personally I like games that move at about a week per turn - around 5 days for the spring / fall and 2 days for the retreats / builds. That seems a good balance of keeping the game hopping and edgy yet still allowing everyone time for real life.

Then there is the WB, which has speedy 2-day turnarounds! How come you aren't playing in that? It seems like just what you're looking for. You might not like the NMR rules tho, of not waiting for missed orders.

If you want to run a game per your style - 24 hour turnarounds and grace periods for missed results, just fill out the "GM a game" form and we'll make it happen! It has been done before, Felix was always a fan of the speedy game, and he had no trouble GM'ing them to a fast schedule.

This message is in reply to post 22328:

There are a lot of websites that use automated judges.



You sure? Where? There are a lot of judges that you submit orders to. But very few actual website based judge sites. The only one I know of is playdiplomacy.com. But they exclusively use CD for NMRs.

I don't see the need for exclusivity. Why can't this site run both judge based games for those that like quicker deadlines as well as human based judges? Why can't it have CD NMR games as well as grace period NMR games? Why the need for just one version?

There are pros and cons to both NMR systems. Really no need to debate the differences. Both are systems used in the Diplomacy world so why not allow for both?

There are 5 Messages in this Thread:


auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs (DucatiRider) Feb 01, 05:18 pm

auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs (Blueraider0) Feb 01, 11:39 pm

auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs (DucatiRider) Feb 02, 09:39 am

auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs (FuzzyLogic) Feb 02, 01:19 pm

auto-Judges and Grace period for NMRs (DucatiRider) Feb 07, 01:22 pm

There are 51 Threads in Help & Suggestions:


Calling all potential GMs (Zoterik)

How to delete account (deletingaccount)

Trouble with RealWorld (BaronVonPWN) [2 Replies]

Flash (trezdk)

How to Change E-mail Address (Ignorance_Is__Sin)

how to submit moves (louwilkinson) [2 Replies]

How DC games are run (LiuPei) [8 Replies]

New Member, how to join a game? (charm)

How can I play? (Matrinsky) [2 Replies]

Inability to Join Game (Bonapartist)

GMing (RedKingofHearts)

inovice 4253499.pdf (AceRimmer)

New games to GM? (Operations)

Realpolitik bug? (Operations) [3 Replies]

Cant update my games (Slangers) [4 Replies]

New GMs (Operations) [2 Replies]

Adjucation (trezdk) [3 Replies]

RealPolitik for Mac (DocFlash) [3 Replies]

Outbound Emails (FuzzyLogic) [2 Replies]

Realpolitik (Slangers) [2 Replies]


1 - 20 of 51 shown [More]

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55608 · Page loaded in 0.3245 seconds by DESMOND