Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  dc212

(Standard)


Post:7977 >
Subject:< dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification >
Topic:< dc212 >
Category:< Closed Games 
Author:David.Ellsworth at dar...
Posted:Dec 10, 2008 at 8:45 am
Viewed:920 times

Avatar

Rank
Rank

Rating: 0

Member SinceLocation
Dec 31, 1969Unknown

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

ONE PLAYER'S OPINION

I am hoping this is not the case, but should Italy not turn in a disband order this winter, what happens?

1. It is my understanding that his Eastern Mediterranean Fleet would be the default disband. Is that correct?

2. Would a NBR put him in Civil Disorder, thus leaving his unit in place for the next year? Would we pause to fill the (extremely) lost position? Would he be allowed to submit orders in the Spring even if he doesn't submit his disband order?

I am concerned about this for it does affect the game somewhat. Should no orders be given for the Italians, Austria will occupy Naples in the Spring and be able to support the defense in the fall. Should an active and concerned Italian player still submit orders, Italy will still very likely be lost by years end, but he could confound things for Austria (most likely), and possibly France, Turkey, and Russia. (not counting indirectly Germany and England.)

Please don't try to read any personal opinion as to what outcome I would prefer. I am only trying to ascertain what dynamics I need to consider. Having been a GM myself, I know the frustrations of losing players and the remaining players needing to adjust to the new dynamic. I am just trying to understand the possible outcomes of a possible NBR.

Jimmy, I know we haven't seen eye to eye on much in this game, but for the sake of the sport, I encourage you to openly let us know if you are still with the game.


David Ellsworth

There are 6 Messages in this Thread:


dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (David.Ellsworth at dar...) Dec 10, 08:45 am

dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (yeeha77) Dec 10, 10:48 am

dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (former.trout) Dec 10, 10:49 am

dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (Verticallychallangedcutie) Dec 10, 05:39 pm

dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (former.trout) Dec 10, 05:47 pm

dc212 1904 Winter Disbands Open Question/Clarification (Jimmy.Ghostine at vtme...) Dec 11, 09:40 am

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55619 · Page loaded in 0.4309 seconds by DESMOND