Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  dc227

(Sudden Variant - GM: White Wolf)


Post:9969 
Subject:< DC-227 Fall 1916 Adjudication >
Topic:< dc227 >
Category:< Closed Games 
Author:TheWhiteWolf
Posted:Mar 30, 2009 at 10:09 pm
Viewed:832 times

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

All,
I have several things to cover, so please pay attention.

First: Babak (Russia) has failed to submit orders. I don't know if he's still having computer trouble or not, but he had eight days to submit orders, plus more than two days' warning. Therefore, I have NMR'ed him. Babak, you have 24 hours to notify me if you wish to remain in the game. If not, I will replace you. If you do get in touch, and continue, the next NMR will cause your immediate replacement, as per rule 2 of my house rules.

Second: In my house rules, I state that extensions will be granted on a case-by-case basis, but that extensions to the current turn are strongly frowned upon. I know I don't specify a time frame in which a request is unacceptable, but asking for an extension less than 12 hours before the deadline, and in the middle of the night before a weekday, won't fly. Even in the case of a family emergency, I could plausibly say that you shouldn't have waited until the day of the deadline to send orders (I wouldn't be that heartless, of course, but it's only common sense.)

Third: Please, for the love of all that's holy, read a GM's house rules either before you sign up for a game, or at least before the game starts. One player submitted an order set that was one order short this turn. When, presumably, he realized his error, he sent an "addition" of the one order. According to my house rules, which I will paste in a moment, this "addition" would be the only valid order, causing the rest of his units to be unordered (hold).
The pertinent rule is: "6c. All order sets should contain a full set of orders. If a subsequent version of orders is sent (i.e., Version 2,) previously received orders will be completely disregarded, regardless of completeness of the most recently received order set. No assumptions will be made as to player intentions for a unit thus unordered."
I did not do that this time, as it would have been detrimental to the game, and it is too late at night to ask guidance of the Mods (and still get the turn out.)

Fourth: PLEASE check a map before submitting orders. Even in a case where you know exactly where all your units are, you should always make sure the spaces you're trying to move them to are adjacent. If the order set in question had been submitted even a day ago, I could have said something like "please review your orders for legality," and at least given some heads up (without crossing into dangerous, GM-interference territory.) However, if I receive orders on the day of the deadline, by the time I check them it will be after the deadline (as I work all day,) and too late to ask clarification. Therefore, potentially flawed order sets can end up affecting your position or plans in the game.

That's all for this turn, I think. Here it is. Any complaints can be addressed to me, though I can't promise I'll change the results. You get what you order, folks.


Players:

Austria: Matt Kelly <kelly058(at)verizon.net>
England: Nick Cherrier <zeclient(at)hotmail.com>
France: Andrew Ott <drew3739o(at)yahoo.com>
Germany: Michael Stroz <mistro914(at)gmail.com>
Italy: Mark Utterbach <mdemagogue(at)gmail.com>
Russia: Babak Talebi <babaktalebi(at)gmail.com>
Turkey: Ilyas Erzik <IErzik(at)mail.az>


Orders:

Austria:
A Budapest - Trieste (*Bounce*)

England:
F Belgium Supports F North Sea - Holland
F Brest Hold
F English Channel Convoys A London - Picardy
F Irish Sea Hold
A London - Picardy
F Mid-Atlantic Ocean Supports F Spain(sc)
F North Sea - Holland
A Norway Supports A Sweden
F Norwegian Sea - North Sea
A Picardy - Burgundy

France:
A Gascony Supports F Spain(sc)
A Marseilles Supports A Picardy - Burgundy (*Cut*)
A Paris Supports A Picardy - Burgundy
F Portugal Supports F Spain(sc)
F Spain(sc) Supports A Marseilles (*Cut*)

Germany:
F Baltic Sea Convoys A Kiel - Denmark (*Void*)
A Burgundy Supports A Piedmont - Marseilles (*Dislodged*)
F Denmark - Skagerrak
F Helgoland Bight Supports F Denmark - Skagerrak (*Fails*)
A Holland Hold (*Dislodged*)
A Kiel - Sweden (*Fails*)
A Munich - Vienna (*Fails*)
A Prussia Supports A Warsaw
A Silesia - Galicia (*Fails*)
A Vienna - Budapest (*Dislodged*)
A Warsaw Supports A Silesia (*Ordered to Move*)

Italy:
F Albania - Greece (*Dislodged*)
F Apulia Supports F Ionian Sea
F Gulf of Lyon Supports F Western Mediterranean - Spain(sc)
F Ionian Sea Hold
F North Africa Hold
A Piedmont - Marseilles (*Fails*)
A Trieste - Vienna
A Tyrolia Supports A Trieste - Vienna
F Tyrrhenian Sea Supports F Ionian Sea
A Venice - Trieste (*Bounce*)
F Western Mediterranean - Spain(sc) (*Fails*)

Russia:
A Galicia, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
F Gulf of Bothnia, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Livonia, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Moscow, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Rumania, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Sevastopol, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A St Petersburg, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Sweden, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)
A Ukraine, no move received (*Ordered to Hold*)

Turkey:
F Aegean Sea Supports F Greece
A Ankara - Armenia
A Bulgaria - Serbia
A Constantinople - Bulgaria
F Eastern Mediterranean - Ionian Sea (*Fails*)
F Greece Supports A Serbia - Albania
A Serbia - Albania
F Smyrna Supports F Aegean Sea


Retreats:

Italian F Albania can retreat to Adriatic Sea or OTB.
German A Burgundy can retreat to Ruhr or OTB.
German A Holland can retreat to Ruhr or OTB.
German A Vienna can retreat to Bohemia or OTB.


Unit Positions: (SCs/Units)

Austria: (2/1)
Armies - Bud

England: (10/10)
Armies - Bur, Nwy, Pic
Fleets - Bel, Bre, Eng, Hol, Iri, MAO, Nth

France: (5/5)
Armies - Gas, Mar, Par
Fleets - Por, Spa(sc)

Germany: (11/11)
Armies - Kie, Mun, Pru, Sil, War,
Bur (pending retreat), Hol (pending retreat), Vie (pending retreat)
Fleets - Bal, Hel, Ska

Italy: (11/11)
Armies - Pie, Trl, Ven, Vie
Fleets - Apu, Ion, Lyo, NAf, Tys, Wes,
Alb (pending retreat)

Russia: (9/9)
Armies - Gal, Lvn, Mos, Rum, Sev, StP, Swe, Ukr
Fleets - Bot

Turkey: (8/Cool
Armies - Alb, Arm, Bul, Ser
Fleets - Aeg, Eas, Gre, Smy


Deadline:

Autumn 1916 Retreats are due Wednesday, 1 April at 2pm CDT (8pm GMT.)
Any issues or errors, let me know.


Map and RP file are attached for your convenience, enjoy!

Thanks all,
The White Wolf

I'm a Firefly fan and proud! Read my fiction:
http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1369632/

There is 1 Message in this Thread:


DC-227 Fall 1916 Adjudication (TheWhiteWolf) Mar 30, 10:09 pm

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55619 · Page loaded in 0.1993 seconds by DESMOND