and here I was thinking it was a really clever use of a little known rules loophole

On Wed, Oct 10, 2012 at 12:06 PM, Pat.C C <patrickcharlescloutier(at)hotmail.com> wrote:




There's a pretty simple explanation  for that move.  I my hurry to get my moves in I neglected to write support in there.
Date: Tue, 9 Oct 2012 23:24:38 -0600
Subject: DC406: Fall 12 Results!

From: mrh(at)panix.com
To: Maxatrest(at)yahoo.co.uk; cbend37(at)aol.com; dance.scholar(at)gmail.com; dc406(at)diplomaticcorp.com; kielmarch(at)hotmail.com; catsfather(at)gmail.com; githraine(at)yahoo.com; hall.jeff(at)gmail.com; jerome777(at)ymail.com; joral(at)darkenedpath.com; justin(at)darkenedpath.com; markjsmith60(at)gmail.com; kremer.matthew(at)gmail.com; mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; mike(at)fuzzylogicllc.net; patrickcharlescloutier(at)hotmail.com; philip.a.hahn(at)gmail.com; psychosis(at)sky.com; rk(at)giorsoine.dk; rolfloschek(at)yahoo.de; tim.diplomacy(at)gmail.com; alwayshunted(at)hotmail.com


Hi All,Y'all have got me confused with this turn. So many twists, so many seeming stabs and yet, not all available stabs were taken.Not a lot of commentary -- you probably read my EOG from my Haven game and I'm still a little weary from it.
So let's just get to the Results.
One funny little turn of a move needs some explanation.  The Knights ordered A Shady -> Sweets, F Cel C Shady -> Sweets, Gurgi S Shady -> Sweets.
Well, the convoy was disrupted by the dislodgement of Celestial. However, the army can move directly to Sweets, and with support, the move succeeds.The original rulebook says all unit moves must be fully written, but later revisions allow for multi-route convoys as well as "convoy or not" if that is an option. 
Personally, I'm a purist and like the original rule, but times change and RealWorld is written with updated rules.
A few retreats are necessary.Adjustments for Fall 12. Deadline is Wednesday, 10/10
========================Dwarves: F Dargaard Keep -> Ken, or OTB              A Dragons Teeth Mtns -> Fion, or OTB              A Land of Sweets -> Fion, or OTB

Knights:F CELESTIAL DELTA -> Mist, Grimpen, Shady, or OTB
Pirates: A Critter Country -> Ele, or OTB

Results for Fall 12:
===================Dwarves: F Loxley Supports F HORNED BAY - PrydainF Vinyaya Supports F CHOCOLATE RIVER - Strawberry FieldsF Grimheim Supports F Ranaar - CELESTIAL DELTA
F Ashan - The Silver cityF Dargaard Keep - EAST SEA OF SHADOWS (*Dislodged*)F Travers Town - RIFT CANYONF Duloc Supports A Neverpeak Mtn - Critter CountryA Cave of Ordeals - Newa River (*Fails*)
A Pygmy Supports F Ashan - The Silver cityA Walk of Clouds - AshanA Dragons Teeth Mtns - River Saeren (*Dislodged*)A Land of Sweets - Gurgi (*Dislodged*)A Daisy Meadows - Acme Acres
A Cliffs of Insanity - LlyrA Tymwyvenne - Cave of Ordeals (*Fails*)A Knurremurre - Tymwyvenne (*Fails*)A Carpantha - Khaz ModanA Ancient Necropolis - YggdrasilF TILVA STRAIT - BEAVERSDAM (*Fails*)
F HIGH SEAS Convoys A Rohan - GrendelF WEST MIRIANIC OCEAN - Walk of CloudsF EAST MIRIANIC OCEAN - NORTH MIRIANIC OCEANF CHOCOLATE RIVER - Strawberry FieldsF RUGGED COAST - HORNED BAY
F HORNED BAY - Prydain
Faeries: A Corona Supports F EAST SEA OF SHADOWS - Dargaard Keep (*Cut*)F POOL OF RADIANCE Supports F EAST SEA OF SHADOWS - Dargaard Keep

Gnomes: A Avalon - Hundred Acre Wood (*Fails*)A Drynwyn - Andarien Plain
Knights: A Hundred Acre Wood Supports A Starkadh - Drynwyn (*Cut*)
A Khemri - DanilothF Newa River, no move receivedA Wing Hove - Heavens WellA Fionavar - River SaerenA Telmar - GrisselF Troldhaugen Supports F Abby Normal - THON THALAS
F Orboros Supports F BEAVERSDAM - The Silver cityA Starkadh - DrynwynA Ice Reach HoldA Kingdom of Hearts Supports A Fionavar - River SaerenA Spiral Castle Supports A Strawberry Fields - Dragons Teeth Mtns
F Gurgi Supports A Shady Vale - Land of SweetsA Shady Vale - Land of SweetsF CRYSTAL LAKE Supports A Ice ReachF CELESTIAL DELTA Convoys A Shady Vale - Land of Sweets (*Dislodged*)
F SUNLESS SEA Convoys A Telmar - GrisselF BEAVERSDAM - The Silver city (*Fails*)F TROG BOG Supports F Troldhaugen
Leprechauns: A Uuno - Horborixen (*Bounce*)

Magicians: A Ergoth - CyrissA Lost Woods Supports F EAST SEA OF SHADOWS - Dargaard KeepF WEST SEA OF SHADOWS - TarsisF EAST SEA OF SHADOWS - Dargaard Keep

Ogres: A Rohan - GrendelF Lubrick - TuathaA Fitzgibbon - LubrickF Lankhmar - THREE RIVER LAKEA Pans Labyrinth - Parce PassA Fjord - Golgafrincham
A Niflheim Supports F THON THALAS - Sorrows EndA Everglot, no move receivedA Fafhrd - Horborixen (*Bounce*)A Devils Canyon - NehwonA Neverpeak Mtn - Critter Country
A Moominvalley Supports F Ashan - The Silver cityF Ithin'Carthia(wc) Supports F RIVER STYX - KrynnA Merrow - NecronomiconA Sinking Shore - Horborixen (*Bounce*)A Powry - Whoville
F Heresh - AllerleirauhA Nowwhat - Venatori UmbrarumF Maze of Regrets Supports A Neverpeak Mtn - Critter CountryF Groves of Academe Supports A Cave of Ordeals - Newa River
F Ranaar - CELESTIAL DELTA
A Venatori Umbrarum - Neverpeak MtnF THON THALAS - Sorrows EndF MERMAIDS LAGOON - RikuF WAY THE HECK Convoys A Rohan - GrendelF THE MAW - RIVER STYXF RIVER STYX - Krynn
F SAVAGE SEA - TimberlandsF GULF OF LUHN - PIRATE SHOALSF ROARING RAPIDS - RIVER OF THE DAWNF THREE RIVER LAKE - GelflingF SEA OF FALLEN STARS Convoys A Rohan - Grendel

Pirates: A Slightly Gulch Supports A Critter Country - Neverpeak MtnF Abby Normal - THON THALASA Critter Country - Neverpeak Mtn (*Dislodged*)A Strawberry Fields - Dragons Teeth Mtns
F GRIEF REEF Supports F Newa River
Undead: A Skellington Supports A EverglotA Palmaris - Corona (*Fails*)F Istar Supports F Dargaard Keep - EAST SEA OF SHADOWS


Thanks,Mike---------
"Sit Long, Talk Much, Laugh Often" -- anon
"Shared Pain is lessened, Shared Joy is increased" --- Spider Robinson







--
It is better to be silent and thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt
-Abraham Lincoln

The problem with Internet quotes is that you can never be certain of their accuracy

-Abraham Lincoln