Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  Winter Blitz

(4th Annual DC Winter Blitz (WB 2011))


Post:2538 
Subject:< DC147 (wb0812) - Spring 1905 English Misorder (?) >
Topic:Winter Blitz >
Category:< Active Games >
Author:test_gm
Posted:Sep 13, 2007 at 12:00 am
Viewed:700 times

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

Hi everyone,

It looks as though I owe you all an apology. One of our good players has pointed out that I was possibly not adjudicating according to the Blitz rules. Specifically the Abbreviations section, which reads:

-----------------------------
Abbreviations
Ambiguous abbreviations will result in a misorder (the unit Holds). An order that could have multiple interpretations will fail. For example F NTH-NOR would fail, because this could mean F NTH-Norway or F NTH-Norwegian Sea. F StP-Nor would be valid since StP can only go to Norway, not Norwegian. "Nor" and "Liv" should be avoided as they can be problematic, although if only one possible order can be made, it will be allowed.
GMs and TDs will not check moves or abbreviations prior to the deadline. Moves will be adjudicated at the deadline and no leniency period to clarify orders will be granted.-------------------------------


The key part of the above passage is "if only one possible order can be made, it will be allowed." England used the 'NOR' abbreviation in the Spring, which would have been ambiguous except that he ordered it to support ENG. As North Sea is the only space beginning with 'NOR' that borders the English Channel, then I ruled that the order had only on possible interpretation.

Hope everyone is all good with this ruling. Please just let me know if you aren't and I will try to explain further...

Cheers,

Trout

There is 1 Message in this Thread:


DC147 (wb0812) - Spring 1905 English Misorder (?) (test_gm) Sep 13, 12:00 am

There are 3710 Threads in Winter Blitz:


One Chair Short Diplomacy (hapolley)

winter Blitz? (bunwarpgazoo)

WB16? (Blueraider0)

Winter Blitz 2015 (gizmo8204)

dc492 four-way draw declared (catsfather) [6 Replies]

dc492 reminder (catsfather) [15 Replies]

dc492 draw proposal (catsfather)

dc492 Spring 1914 (catsfather)

dc492 Winter 1913 (catsfather)

dc492 Fall 1913 (catsfather)

dc492 Summer 1913 (catsfather)

dc492 Spring 1913 (catsfather)

dc492 Fall 1912 (catsfather) [6 Replies]

dc492 Summer 1912 (catsfather)

dc492 Spring 1912 (catsfather)

dc492 Winter 1911 (catsfather)

dc492 Fall 1911 (catsfather)

dc492 Summer 1911 (catsfather)

dc492 Spring 1911 (catsfather)

Fwd: dc492 Winter 1910 (catsfather)


1 - 20 of 3710 shown [More]

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55613 · Page loaded in 0.2542 seconds by DESMOND