Both votes fail.  There's a request to release the numbers of who voted for and who voted against.  I *expect* this is against the rules, but I'll check tomorrow morning.

Anyway, English A Ruhr can retreat to Holland.  
Shall we just assume it?

H



Movement results for Spring of 1909.  (dc482)

 
England: A Clyde Hold.

England: F Irish Sea Supports F Portugal - Mid-Atlantic Ocean.

England: A Ruhr Supports A Holland - Belgium (*Dislodged*).

 
Germany: A Brest - Picardy.

Germany: F Denmark Supports A Kiel.

Germany: A Holland - Belgium.

Germany: A Kiel Supports A Ruhr (*Cut*).

Germany: A Norway - Finland.

Germany: F Norwegian Sea - Norway (*Bounce*).

Germany: A Paris Supports A Gascony - Burgundy.

 
Italy: A Gascony - Burgundy.

Italy: F Gulf of Lyon - Tyrrhenian Sea (*Bounce*).

Italy: A Marseilles - Piedmont.

Italy: F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - North Africa.

Italy: F Naples - Ionian Sea (*Bounce*).

Italy: F Portugal - Mid-Atlantic Ocean.

Italy: F Spain(sc) - Western Mediterranean.

 
Turkey: F Aegean Sea - Ionian Sea (*Bounce*).

Turkey: A Ankara - Constantinople (*Fails*).

Turkey: A Belgium - Ruhr.

Turkey: A Berlin - Kiel (*Fails*).

Turkey: F Constantinople - Aegean Sea (*Fails*).

Turkey: F Greece - Albania.

Turkey: A Moscow - Livonia.

Turkey: A Munich Supports A Belgium - Ruhr.

Turkey: F North Atlantic Ocean - Norwegian Sea (*Fails*).

Turkey: F Smyrna - Eastern Mediterranean.

Turkey: A St Petersburg - Norway (*Bounce*).

Turkey: F Tunis - Tyrrhenian Sea (*Bounce*).

Turkey: A Tyrolia - Venice.

Turkey: A Warsaw - Silesia.

 
The following units were dislodged:

 
English A Ruhr can retreat to Holland.

 
Unit locations:

 
England:   A Clyde, F Irish Sea.

Germany:   A Belgium, F Denmark, A Finland, A Kiel, F Norwegian Sea, A Paris, A 

           Picardy.

Italy:     A Burgundy, F Gulf of Lyon, F Mid-Atlantic Ocean, F Naples, F North 

           Africa, A Piedmont, F Western Mediterranean.

Turkey:    F Aegean Sea, F Albania, A Ankara, A Berlin, F Constantinople, F 

           Eastern Mediterranean, A Livonia, A Munich, F North Atlantic Ocean, 

           A Ruhr, A Silesia, A St Petersburg, F Tunis, A Venice.

 
Ownership of supply centers:

 
England:   Edinburgh, Liverpool, London.

Germany:   Brest, Denmark, Holland, Kiel, Norway, Paris, Sweden.

Italy:     Marseilles, Naples, Portugal, Rome, Spain, Trieste, Venice.

Turkey:    Ankara, Belgium, Berlin, Budapest, Bulgaria, Constantinople, Greece, 

           Moscow, Munich, Rumania, Serbia, Sevastopol, Smyrna, St Petersburg, 

           Tunis, Vienna, Warsaw.

 
Austria:    0 Supply centers,  0 Units:  Builds   0 units.

England:    3 Supply centers,  2 Units:  Builds   0 units.

France:     0 Supply centers,  0 Units:  Builds   0 units.

Germany:    7 Supply centers,  7 Units:  Builds   0 units.

Italy:      7 Supply centers,  7 Units:  Builds   0 units.

Russia:     0 Supply centers,  0 Units:  Builds   0 units.

Turkey:    17 Supply centers, 14 Units:  Builds   1 unit.

 
The next phase of dc482 will be Retreats for Spring of 1909.