Diplomaticcorp - Forum Post

Welcome Guest! [Log In] [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum: Community

(community(at)diplomaticcorp(dot)com)

Messages:

New Post
List of Topics
Recent Messages

Preview:

Compact
Brief
Full

Replies:

Hide All
Show All

Post:	< 18449 >
Subject:	< For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question >
Topic:	Community >
Category:	General >
Author:	s2000chops
Posted:	Nov 11, 2010 at 11:25 am
Viewed:	1411 times

S2000chops

Order of the Parchment

Balance: For Aristotle, the Golden Mean was the desired middle between two extremes. The Knight of the Parchment uses the written word to stake out this middle ground between action and inaction. Facillitated only by constant communication, the balance between harsh aggression and modest acquisition is the art of diplomacy.

Order of the Parchment

Rating: 1198

Member Since	Location
Sep 30, 2000	USA, New York

[New Post] [Reply] [Quote]

I think, for the same reason, that order #2 (with A Bel - Par) should also be valid. Par is not a valid destination from Belgium, so the move is invalid and the unit holds.

The NAF case is the trickiest one; what's the wording on armies being convoyed?

This message is in reply to post 18445:

Upon further review, I believe even #5 is clear:

An Army can be ordered to move into an adjacent inland or coastal province.

and...

A Fleet can be ordered to move to an adjacent water province or coastal province.

So the manual defines movement as only valid when ordering to an ADJACENT province. (not to the province itself). So Bel-Bel is definitely not a valid move order. The unit holds, support for it holding is valid.

There are 16 Messages in this Thread:

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (AceRimmer) Nov 10, 10:06 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 10, 09:39 pm

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 10, 09:54 pm

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (s2000chops) Nov 11, 11:25 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (garry.bledsoe) Nov 11, 03:29 pm

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Blueraider0) Nov 12, 02:07 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (AceRimmer) Nov 12, 10:14 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (AceRimmer) Nov 12, 10:23 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Blueraider0) Nov 13, 12:12 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 15, 09:49 am

Reply notification (AceRimmer) Nov 15, 10:56 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 15, 11:20 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (Blueraider0) Nov 19, 01:49 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 19, 08:48 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (AceRimmer) Nov 19, 11:17 am

For GMs: Invalid order - Support Question (FuzzyLogic) Nov 19, 12:05 pm

There are 181 Threads in Community:

Back after a while and hoping to play. (diplocowboy) [2 Replies]

Back after a while and hoping to play. (diplocowboy)

DC Games (DealingFungus66)

Cousins game (Sean2010) [3 Replies]

Cousins game (Sean2010)

Looking for one more player (Slangers)

Just Joined (Spindoctor6)

is DC dead ? (ruler462)

Brother's War (Conquest) (Sean2010)

Getting Started (DealingFungus66)

Sign Ups not working (umbletheheep)

2021 Winter Blitz? (umbletheheep)

PERFIDIOUS#2 (THC)

A Dip Read (THC)

Time for Games? (garry.bledsoe)

Spaces for Standard players (Slangers)

Offering a new way to play Diplomacy (Slangers)

New Member (Skeleton) [2 Replies]

First Intimate Game Ends! (Slangers)

Weekly Diplomacy Newsletter (umbletheheep)

1 - 20 of 181 shown [More]

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.